Based on checking the website Pay4junkcar.com, it appears to be a local service focused on buying junk cars in Columbus, OH.
While the concept of selling a used or non-functional vehicle seems straightforward, a deeper look into the website’s presentation and the nature of such transactions reveals several points worth considering, particularly from an ethical and transparency standpoint.
Overall Review Summary:
- Purpose: Buying junk cars, trucks, SUVs, and vans in Columbus, OH.
- Payment: Offers “top dollar” cash for vehicles, ranging from $100 to $15,000.
- Services: Free towing provided for purchased vehicles.
- Location: Primarily serves Columbus, OH, and surrounding areas.
- Contact Information: Phone number 614 974-6622, physical address: 3507 Groveport East Rd, Columbus, OH 43207, United States.
- Operating Hours: Monday to Saturday: 8:30 am–5:30 pm.
- Key Claims: “No hidden fee or any kind of deduction,” “pick up junk car as soon as possible.”
The website itself is quite basic, providing essential contact information and a brief overview of services.
However, for a transaction involving variable cash amounts and vehicle conditions, there’s a significant lack of detailed information that typically instills confidence in consumers.
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. |
Amazon.com:
Check Amazon for Pay4junkcar.com Review Latest Discussions & Reviews: |
This includes an absence of clear terms and conditions, a privacy policy, or a robust FAQ section that addresses common concerns beyond just the basics.
While the service itself—selling a non-functional asset—is permissible, the opaqueness can lead to uncertainty and potential issues.
Here are some better alternatives for handling end-of-life vehicles or other practical needs, focusing on transparency and comprehensive service:
-
Vehicle Donation Programs:
- Product Name: Goodwill Car Donation Program
- Key Features: Accepts cars, trucks, RVs, motorcycles, boats, and other vehicles. provides tax deduction for your donation. proceeds support community programs.
- Price/Average Price: No cash payment. provides a tax receipt for the fair market value.
- Pros: Supports a charitable cause. hassle-free pick-up. potential tax benefits.
- Cons: No direct cash payment.
-
Reputable Used Car Marketplaces for functional vehicles:
- Product Name: CarGurus
- Key Features: Large inventory of used cars, transparent pricing analysis, dealer and private seller options, detailed vehicle histories.
- Price/Average Price: Varies based on vehicle and market.
- Pros: Wide selection, strong vetting of sellers, good for finding competitive deals.
- Cons: Not suitable for non-functional or “junk” cars. requires more effort for selling.
-
Online Vehicle Appraisal and Sale Platforms:
- Product Name: Peddle
- Key Features: Provides instant offers for cars in any condition including junk cars. free towing. direct payment. works nationwide.
- Price/Average Price: Offers vary based on vehicle condition, make, model, and market demand.
- Pros: Convenient, quick process, handles all conditions, nationwide service.
- Cons: Offers might be lower than private sale for functional cars.
-
Local Auto Parts Recycling Centers for ethical disposal:
- Product Name: U-Pull-It Auto Parts Search for local centers
- Key Features: Buys vehicles for parts and scrap metal. focuses on environmental responsibility. typically transparent about pricing based on weight/condition.
- Price/Average Price: Varies, generally based on vehicle weight and metal prices.
- Pros: Environmentally conscious disposal, often provides cash for scrap.
- Cons: May require delivery of the vehicle, or offers might be lower than for functional vehicles.
-
Professional Towing and Vehicle Removal Services:
- Product Name: AAA Roadside Assistance For members, other services might be paid
- Key Features: Offers towing, battery jump-starts, tire changes, and other emergency roadside services. While not a junk car buyer, it’s a critical service for moving non-functional vehicles.
- Price/Average Price: Membership fee for AAA. individual towing services vary.
- Pros: Reliable for emergencies, wide network, professional service.
- Cons: Not a service for selling junk cars. requires membership for full benefits.
-
Local Scrap Metal Dealers for raw materials:
- Product Name: Local Scrap Metal Recyclers Search for local facilities
- Key Features: Buys various types of metal, including automotive scrap. Prices are typically based on current market rates for different metals.
- Price/Average Price: Varies daily based on global metal commodity prices.
- Pros: Direct cash for scrap, environmentally responsible, clear pricing.
- Cons: Requires vehicle to be stripped down or delivered. offers generally lower than for complete vehicles.
-
Public Transportation and Ride-Sharing as an alternative to owning a problematic car:
- Product Name: Local Public Transit Authority e.g., COTA in Columbus, OH / Uber
- Key Features: Provides a reliable and often cost-effective alternative to vehicle ownership, especially for those with non-functional cars. Reduces environmental impact.
- Price/Average Price: Public transit fares are typically low. ride-sharing costs vary by distance and demand.
- Pros: Eliminates car maintenance costs, reduces carbon footprint, convenient for many trips.
- Cons: May not be suitable for all travel needs or rural areas.
Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.
IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.
Pay4junkcar.com Review & First Look
When you land on Pay4junkcar.com, the first impression is that of a highly localized, straightforward service.
The website immediately hits you with a phone number, a call to action “Get Cash for Your Junk Car”, and a form to fill out for a quote.
This direct approach might appeal to someone in a hurry to offload a vehicle that’s become a literal eyesore or burden.
The core message is clear: they buy junk cars in Columbus, OH, and offer free towing.
Initial Impressions of the Website Design
The design of Pay4junkcar.com is undeniably minimalist. Cathycena.com Review
It prioritizes functionality over aesthetics, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing for a service-oriented site.
There are no flashy animations, complex navigation menus, or extensive content pages.
It’s essentially a single-page layout with a few internal links to the same content.
- Simplicity: The layout is clean, making it easy to find the most critical information: contact details and the purpose of the business.
- Direct Call to Action: The prominent phone number and “CALL TO GET QUOTE” buttons ensure users know exactly what to do next.
- Mobile Responsiveness: The site generally adapts well to different screen sizes, which is crucial given that many users will likely access it from their phones.
- Lack of Depth: While simple, it lacks the depth of information that builds trust and provides comprehensive details about the transaction process.
Overview of Services Offered
Pay4junkcar.com explicitly states its primary service: buying junk cars, trucks, SUVs, and vans of “all year, make, model and condition” within the Columbus, OH area.
They highlight key scenarios like vehicles with “bad engine, damaged, bad transmission, wrecked, old, unwanted, etc.” Garageamvb.com Review
- Free Towing: This is a significant benefit, as towing a non-functional vehicle can be costly and logistically challenging for the owner.
- Quick Cash Offers: The site emphasizes “top dollar” quotes and a desire to “make some quick cash.”
- No Hidden Fees: A crucial claim, asserting “There is no hidden fee or any kind of deduction.” This promise aims to reassure potential sellers about transparent pricing.
Geographical Focus and Local Reach
The website’s content is heavily concentrated on Columbus, OH.
Phrases like “We buy junk cars in Columbus OH,” “junkyard in Columbus Ohio,” and “sell your junk car in Columbus Ohio” are repeated frequently.
This hyper-local focus suggests that they operate within a defined service radius, which can be beneficial for efficiency but limits broader appeal.
- Targeted Audience: Clearly aims for residents within Columbus and surrounding areas.
- Logistical Advantage: Operating locally often means faster pick-up times, as claimed by the site “pick up junk car as soon as possible”.
Pay4junkcar.com Pros & Cons
A critical review of Pay4junkcar.com reveals both potential advantages for a seller and significant areas where the website falls short in terms of transparency and building consumer confidence.
Identified Strengths and Benefits Pros
While the website’s minimalist design limits comprehensive insights, a few potential pros can be inferred from the direct messaging: Eadocx.com Review
- Simplicity and Directness: The site is incredibly easy to navigate. If you’re looking for a quick phone number to call and get rid of a junk car, it delivers that immediately. This can be a benefit for users who prefer minimal online interaction.
- Free Towing: This is a significant advantage. The cost of towing a non-functional vehicle can eat into any money you receive for it, so having this service included is a strong selling point. According to Consumer Reports, unexpected towing costs can range from $50 to over $200 depending on distance and vehicle type, highlighting the value of this offering.
- Focus on Any Condition: The willingness to buy cars with “bad engine, damaged, bad transmission, wrecked, old, unwanted, etc.” is a clear benefit for owners of truly derelict vehicles that might be difficult to sell elsewhere. This caters to a very specific pain point.
- Local Service in Columbus, OH: For residents of Columbus, OH, and surrounding areas, a local buyer can mean faster response times and more personalized service compared to larger national chains.
- Claim of “No Hidden Fees”: If this claim holds true, it’s a major plus. Hidden fees can be a common frustration in vehicle sales, so a transparent, final offer is highly desirable.
Areas for Improvement and Potential Drawbacks Cons
This is where Pay4junkcar.com shows considerable room for improvement, particularly when judged against best practices for online business legitimacy and consumer protection.
- Lack of Transparency: This is the most significant drawback.
- No Clear Process Description: The website doesn’t detail the steps involved after making the initial call or filling the form. What happens next? How is the quote determined? What documents are needed?
- Absence of Terms and Conditions: A reputable business, especially one dealing with vehicle transactions and cash payments, should have easily accessible terms and conditions outlining the agreement between the buyer and seller. This protects both parties.
- No Privacy Policy: Handling personal information even just a phone number or email without a clear privacy policy is a red flag. Users need to know how their data is collected, used, and protected. According to the California Consumer Privacy Act CCPA and General Data Protection Regulation GDPR, transparency regarding data handling is increasingly a legal and ethical expectation.
- No Customer Reviews or Testimonials: The absence of on-site testimonials or links to third-party review platforms like Google Reviews, Yelp, or BBB makes it difficult for potential sellers to gauge the experiences of previous customers. This significantly impacts trust.
- Limited Information About the Business: Beyond a physical address and phone number, there’s little information about the company itself.
- No “About Us” Section: Who runs Pay4junkcar.com? How long have they been in business beyond “over decades”? This lack of background information can make the business seem less established or legitimate.
- No Licensing/Accreditation Details: As a junkyard or vehicle dismantler, are they licensed by the state of Ohio? Are they accredited by any industry bodies? This information is crucial for compliance and trust.
- Basic Website Functionality:
- No Online Quote System: While there’s a form, it doesn’t provide an instant online quote. This requires manual follow-up, which can be less convenient for users accustomed to immediate digital responses.
- Generic Content: The text is repetitive and lacks unique details that would distinguish it from many other local junk car buyers.
- Potential for Misleading “Top Dollar” Claims: While they claim “top dollar,” without a clear appraisal process or comparison to market rates, this claim is subjective and unverified. The actual offer can vary widely based on the vehicle’s true condition and the fluctuating price of scrap metal. The average price of scrap steel, a major component of junk cars, can fluctuate significantly, impacting what buyers can offer.
- Security Concerns: The absence of an SSL certificate for the website indicated by “http://” instead of “https://” means data submitted through the form is not encrypted. This is a significant security vulnerability, especially if users are asked to provide more sensitive information beyond basic contact details. As of 2024, an SSL certificate is considered a baseline security requirement for any website, particularly those handling user input.
In summary, while Pay4junkcar.com offers a convenient solution for offloading a junk car with free towing, its critical shortcomings in transparency, detailed process explanation, and consumer trust elements like reviews and clear policies suggest a cautious approach for potential sellers.
How to Cancel Pay4junkcar.com “Subscription” Not Applicable
Given that Pay4junkcar.com operates as a service for buying junk cars rather than offering any ongoing service or digital product, the concept of “canceling a subscription” or a “free trial” does not apply.
Pay4junkcar.com is a transactional business.
You contact them, they make an offer for your vehicle, and if you accept, they buy it and tow it away. This is a one-time transaction for each vehicle. Mooremodz.weebly.com Review
There are no recurring fees, memberships, or trials involved.
Understanding the Transactional Nature of the Service
When you engage with Pay4junkcar.com, you are entering into a direct sale agreement for a physical asset your vehicle. This is distinct from:
- Software as a Service SaaS: Where you pay a recurring fee for access to software.
- Content Subscriptions: Like streaming services or online newspapers.
- Membership Sites: Where you pay to access exclusive content or community features.
- Trial Periods: Where you use a service for free for a limited time before committing to a paid plan.
Therefore, if you have contacted Pay4junkcar.com and received a quote, and you decide not to proceed, there is nothing to “cancel.” You simply decline the offer.
If they have already picked up your car and paid you, the transaction is complete, and no further action is required.
What to Do If You’ve Engaged and Changed Your Mind
If you’ve initiated contact with Pay4junkcar.com but no transaction has been completed, and you wish to disengage, simply: Etymonline.com Review
- Decline the Offer: If they have given you a quote, politely inform them you are not interested in proceeding.
- Cease Communication: If you filled out a form but haven’t heard back, or if you’ve had an initial call, you can simply choose not to respond to any further contact from them.
- No Formal Cancellation Needed: There is no “cancellation process” because there’s no ongoing commitment or subscription to terminate.
In essence, your interaction with Pay4junkcar.com begins and ends with the potential sale of your vehicle, without any lingering financial or contractual obligations typically associated with subscriptions or trials.
Pay4junkcar.com Pricing
Pay4junkcar.com states that they offer “top dollar” for junk cars, with a broad range of $100 – $15,000. This wide spectrum immediately indicates that the actual price you receive will be highly dependent on the specifics of your vehicle.
How Offers are Determined Inferred
While the website doesn’t explicitly detail its appraisal process, common practices in the junk car buying industry suggest that the offer is typically based on several factors:
- Vehicle Make, Model, and Year: Newer or more popular models, even if damaged, might yield more valuable salvageable parts.
- Condition of the Vehicle: This is paramount. A car with a perfectly good engine but a rusted body will be valued differently than a car with a pristine body but a seized engine. The website specifically mentions buying vehicles with “bad engine, damaged, bad transmission, wrecked, old, unwanted, etc.,” indicating a willingness to take on various levels of damage.
- Current Scrap Metal Prices: A significant portion of a junk car’s value comes from its weight in scrap metal steel, aluminum, copper. These commodity prices fluctuate daily, impacting the base value of the vehicle. For example, the average price for shredded scrap steel in the U.S. can range from $250-$400 per ton, but this is subject to significant market volatility, as reported by industry indices like the American Metal Market AMM or CRU.
- Salvageable Parts: If the vehicle has functional components e.g., tires, intact interior, specific engine parts that can be resold, this adds to its value.
- Market Demand for Parts: The demand for used parts of a particular make and model in the local area can influence the offer.
- Towing Costs Factored In: Although they offer “free towing,” the cost of towing is inherently built into the operational expenses of the business and thus indirectly impacts the offer they can afford to give. A longer towing distance might mean a slightly lower offer.
- Operating Costs and Profit Margin: Like any business, they need to cover their operational costs labor, yard maintenance, processing, fuel, insurance and make a profit.
The “No Hidden Fee” Claim
Pay4junkcar.com prominently claims, “There is no hidden fee or any kind of deduction.” If this is true, it means the quote they provide is the final amount you receive.
This is a significant advantage, as unexpected fees e.g., for “environmental disposal” or “administrative costs” can often reduce the final payout from less scrupulous buyers. Greenbit.cc Review
Price Range: $100 – $15,000
The vast range from $100 to $15,000 is typical for junk car buyers, as it accounts for the extreme differences in vehicle value.
- $100: This lowest end is likely for vehicles that are truly just scrap metal—perhaps very old, completely stripped, heavily damaged, or missing critical components. It’s barely above the cost of simple towing.
- $15,000: This higher end would only be for very specific vehicles. It could imply:
- A newer model with significant damage but still highly valuable components e.g., a luxury car with a wrecked body but a good powertrain.
- A classic car that is “junk” in the sense of being non-functional but has a high restoration value.
- A heavy-duty truck or commercial vehicle that yields a large amount of valuable scrap or components.
- It’s important for sellers not to expect the high end of this range unless their vehicle is exceptional.
Key Considerations for Sellers Regarding Pricing
- Get Multiple Quotes: Because the pricing is not transparent online, sellers should always call multiple junk car buyers to compare offers. This is the best way to ensure you’re getting a competitive price.
- Be Honest About Condition: Providing an accurate description of your vehicle’s condition engine issues, body damage, missing parts will help you get a more accurate quote and avoid disputes at pickup.
- Understand Scrap Value vs. Part Value: A vehicle that can be salvaged for parts will almost always command a higher price than one that is only valuable for its scrap metal.
- Market Fluctuations: Be aware that the value of scrap metal changes, which can impact the offer over time.
In conclusion, while Pay4junkcar.com advertises a broad price range and claims “no hidden fees,” the actual offer is determined offline.
Sellers should manage their expectations, understand the factors influencing the price, and always seek multiple quotes to ensure a fair deal.
Pay4junkcar.com vs. Competitors
When considering selling a junk car, Pay4junkcar.com is just one option among many, especially in a metropolitan area like Columbus, OH.
Understanding how it stacks up against competitors involves looking at various types of buyers and their operational models. Fullertonmedical.net Review
The competition generally falls into a few categories: local junkyards/salvage yards, online aggregators, and individual scrap metal dealers.
Local Junkyards / Salvage Yards Direct Competitors
These are the most direct competitors to Pay4junkcar.com, as they operate with a similar business model: buying vehicles for parts, scrap, or resale.
- Examples in Columbus, OH: While specific names aren’t provided on Pay4junkcar.com, a quick search for “junkyards Columbus OH” or “cash for cars Columbus” reveals numerous local businesses like:
- Columbus Pick-n-Pull: Often focuses on allowing customers to pull their own parts, but also buys cars for scrap.
- Various small, independent salvage yards.
- Similarities to Pay4junkcar.com:
- Offer cash for junk cars.
- Often provide free towing.
- Operate within a specific local service area.
- Prices are determined by vehicle condition, parts value, and scrap metal rates.
- Key Differences:
- Online Presence: Some may have more developed websites with online quote forms, detailed FAQs, or customer review sections.
- Specialties: Some might specialize in specific makes/models for parts, potentially offering slightly higher prices for those.
- Reputation/Reviews: Established local yards often have a longer track record of customer reviews, which can build trust. Pay4junkcar.com lacks this on its own site.
- Transparency: Competitors might be more upfront about their process or requirements.
Online Aggregators / Nationwide Buyers
These companies act as brokers or direct buyers on a larger scale, often operating across multiple states.
- Examples: Peddle, CarBrain, Wheelzy.
- Buy cars in “any” condition, including non-running vehicles.
- Often include free towing.
- Aim for a quick, hassle-free process.
- Instant Online Quotes: A major differentiator. You can typically get a firm offer online within minutes by inputting vehicle details, without needing to call. This provides immediate transparency.
- Nationwide Reach: They are not limited to a single city, offering convenience for a broader customer base.
- Professionalism/Branding: Generally have more sophisticated websites, clear terms, privacy policies, and dedicated customer support.
- Payment Methods: May offer various payment methods beyond just cash e.g., check, direct deposit.
- Network of Towing Partners: They often work with local towing companies, so while the offer comes from the aggregator, a local partner handles the pickup.
- Price Competitiveness: While convenient, their offers might sometimes be slightly lower than a very aggressive local buyer, as they have larger overheads and operational costs. However, they provide certainty.
Individual Scrap Metal Dealers
While some junkyards double as scrap metal dealers, dedicated scrap yards focus primarily on the metal content.
- Examples: Local ferrous and non-ferrous metal recycling centers.
- Will pay cash based on weight.
- Focus on the raw materials.
- Vehicle Condition: They might only be interested in the vehicle for its metal, not for parts. This means severely damaged or stripped vehicles are their primary target.
- Towing: They may not offer free towing, requiring the seller to transport the vehicle themselves or arrange separate towing, which can significantly reduce the net payout.
- Pricing Basis: Their offers are almost solely based on the current market price of scrap steel and other metals by weight.
- Focus: Less about convenience and more about raw material procurement.
Overall Competitive Standpoint for Pay4junkcar.com
Pay4junkcar.com appears to be a very localized player aiming for direct phone-based transactions. Lovenesslondon.com Review
Its main competitive edge is likely its local presence and the promise of free towing and “no hidden fees.” However, its lack of online transparency no T&Cs, privacy policy, or integrated reviews and the absence of an instant online quote system put it at a disadvantage compared to more established online aggregators and some more digitally-savvy local competitors.
For a seller, the best approach is always to:
- Gather Multiple Quotes: Call Pay4junkcar.com and several other local junkyards/salvage yards.
- Check Online Aggregators: Get instant offers from Peddle or CarBrain.
- Compare Services: Consider not just the price, but also the ease of pickup, required documentation, and stated terms.
This multi-faceted approach ensures the seller gets the most competitive offer and the most reliable service for their specific vehicle and situation.
FAQ
What is Pay4junkcar.com?
Pay4junkcar.com is a service based in Columbus, OH, that buys junk cars, trucks, SUVs, and vans of various conditions for cash.
They also offer free towing for vehicles they purchase. Getawayasap.com Review
Does Pay4junkcar.com operate nationwide?
No, based on its website content, Pay4junkcar.com appears to operate exclusively in Columbus, OH, and its surrounding areas.
What kind of vehicles does Pay4junkcar.com buy?
Pay4junkcar.com buys vehicles of all years, makes, models, and conditions, including those with bad engines, damaged bodies, bad transmissions, wrecked, old, or unwanted vehicles.
How much cash can I get for my junk car from Pay4junkcar.com?
Pay4junkcar.com states that offers range from $100 to $15,000, with the exact amount depending on the specific vehicle’s condition, make, model, and current market values for parts and scrap metal.
Does Pay4junkcar.com charge for towing?
No, Pay4junkcar.com explicitly states that they provide free towing service for all the junk cars they buy in the Columbus, OH area.
Are there any hidden fees with Pay4junkcar.com?
Pay4junkcar.com claims there are “no hidden fee or any kind of deduction,” suggesting the quote you receive will be the final payout amount. Infotai.com Review
How do I get a quote from Pay4junkcar.com?
You can get a quote by calling or texting them at 614 974-6622, or by filling out the form on their website.
What information do I need to provide to get a quote?
While not explicitly stated, you will likely need to provide details about your vehicle, such as its make, model, year, and a description of its current condition e.g., if it runs, has a bad engine, body damage.
How quickly does Pay4junkcar.com pick up vehicles?
Pay4junkcar.com claims to “pick up junk car as soon as possible” after an offer is accepted.
What are Pay4junkcar.com’s operating hours?
Pay4junkcar.com operates Monday to Saturday, from 8:30 am to 5:30 pm.
Does Pay4junkcar.com have an “About Us” section?
No, the website does not feature a dedicated “About Us” section that provides detailed information about the company’s history, mission, or team. Kuitego.com Review
Is Pay4junkcar.com a legitimate business?
Pay4junkcar.com provides a physical address and phone number, suggesting it is a real local business.
However, the lack of a privacy policy, terms and conditions, or customer reviews on its site makes it harder to fully assess its legitimacy and transparency.
Does Pay4junkcar.com have a privacy policy?
No, the Pay4junkcar.com website does not have a readily accessible privacy policy, which is a significant drawback for user data transparency.
Does Pay4junkcar.com have customer reviews or testimonials?
The website itself does not display any customer reviews or testimonials.
It’s advisable to search for third-party reviews on platforms like Google or Yelp if available. Websolindia.com Review
Is my personal information secure on Pay4junkcar.com?
The website uses “http://” rather than “https://,” indicating it lacks an SSL certificate.
This means any information you submit through their online form is not encrypted and could be vulnerable.
Can I sell a non-running car to Pay4junkcar.com?
Yes, Pay4junkcar.com states they buy vehicles in various non-running conditions, including those with bad engines or transmissions.
What documents do I need to sell my car to Pay4junkcar.com?
The website does not specify required documentation, but typically, you would need the vehicle’s title proof of ownership and a valid ID. It’s best to confirm this when you call.
How does Pay4junkcar.com compare to national junk car buyers like Peddle or CarBrain?
Pay4junkcar.com is a local service with a more basic online presence, requiring phone calls for quotes. Myrefund.org Review
National buyers like Peddle often offer instant online quotes and have more comprehensive websites with clear policies, though they may work with local partners for pickup.
Is it better to sell to a local junkyard or an online aggregator?
It depends.
Local junkyards like Pay4junkcar.com might offer slightly higher prices if they have specific demand for your car’s parts, but online aggregators often provide more immediate, transparent quotes and broader service areas. It’s always best to get multiple quotes.
What if I fill out the form but don’t want to proceed?
Since Pay4junkcar.com is a transactional service not a subscription, if you fill out the form or get a quote but decide not to proceed, there is nothing to “cancel.” You simply decline the offer or cease communication.
Leave a Reply