Why Hardblock.com.au (and Bitcoin) is Problematic from an Islamic Perspective 1 by Partners

Why Hardblock.com.au (and Bitcoin) is Problematic from an Islamic Perspective

Updated on

hardblock.com.au Logo

From an Islamic standpoint, engaging with platforms like Hardblock.com.au for buying Bitcoin presents a fundamental conflict with established financial principles. Islam strongly discourages investments based on excessive speculation (gharar), promotes tangible assets, and forbids practices that resemble riba (interest/usury) or contribute to societal harm. Bitcoin, by its very nature, embodies gharar due to its extreme volatility and lack of intrinsic value tied to a productive asset. Its value is driven by market sentiment and speculative demand, making it a highly uncertain and often unpredictable store of wealth. While proponents may argue for its decentralisation and limited supply, these technical characteristics do not override the core issue of its speculative nature. Investing in Bitcoin, therefore, is not viewed as a permissible form of wealth generation or preservation in Islamic finance, which prioritises real economic activity, ethical partnerships, and the sharing of genuine risk and reward.

Read more about hardblock.com.au:
Hardblock.com.au Review & First Look
Hardblock.com.au: An Assessment of its Core Offering

The Principle of Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty)

One of the primary reasons Bitcoin is problematic in Islamic finance is the principle of gharar, which translates to excessive uncertainty or ambiguity in a transaction. Islamic finance prohibits transactions with significant gharar because they introduce undue risk, can lead to disputes, and resemble gambling. Bitcoin’s value is highly volatile, often experiencing drastic price swings within short periods, driven by market sentiment, news, and speculative trading rather than fundamental economic indicators or tangible asset backing. This inherent volatility and unpredictability make it a classic example of an asset riddled with gharar. A Muslim is advised to invest in assets where the outcome is reasonably certain, or where the risks are clearly understood and shared. The speculative nature of Bitcoin falls squarely outside these parameters, making it an unsuitable investment for those adhering to Islamic financial principles.

Lack of Intrinsic Value and Tangible Backing

In Islamic economics, money and wealth are ideally tied to tangible assets or productive economic activity. Gold, silver, and commodities have historically served as acceptable forms of currency because they possess intrinsic value or are linked to real-world goods. Shares in a company are permissible if the company’s underlying business activities are ethical and productive, as they represent ownership in a real enterprise. Bitcoin, on the other hand, lacks any intrinsic value. It is not backed by a physical commodity, nor does it represent ownership in a productive asset. Its value is purely derived from human consensus, demand, and scarcity within a digital network. This detachment from tangible economic reality makes it fundamentally different from permissible forms of wealth and investment in Islam. Wealth accumulation through non-productive, speculative assets is generally discouraged, as it can lead to economic instability and inequity.

The Speculative Nature vs. Productive Investment

Hardblock.com.au, like many crypto platforms, highlights Bitcoin’s historical price appreciation, framing it as an opportunity for significant returns. This focus on capital gains derived from price fluctuations rather than from productive economic activity is another red flag from an Islamic perspective. Islamic finance encourages investment in real businesses, agriculture, or trade where wealth is generated through effort, innovation, and value creation. This is known as mudharabah (profit-sharing partnership) or musharakah (joint venture), where risks and rewards are shared in a tangible enterprise. Speculation, where profit is primarily derived from buying low and selling high in a volatile market with no underlying productive asset, is akin to gambling and is generally prohibited. The emphasis on “saving in the hardest monetary asset” within the context of Bitcoin’s price movements directly promotes a speculative mindset over a productive one, which is contrary to Islamic teachings on wealth accumulation.

0.0
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Amazon.com: Check Amazon for Why Hardblock.com.au (and
Latest Discussions & Reviews:

Ethical Concerns Regarding Illicit Activities

While Hardblock.com.au is a regulated entity, the broader nature of decentralised cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin means they can, at times, be used for activities that are impermissible or illegal under Islamic law. The pseudonymous nature of Bitcoin transactions can potentially facilitate money laundering, financing of illicit activities, or avoidance of zakat (obligatory charity) obligations. While Hardblock.com.au claims to be AUSTRAC registered (which implies anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing compliance), the inherent characteristics of Bitcoin’s design could, in theory, be exploited outside regulated exchanges. Muslims are enjoined to ensure their wealth is acquired and used in lawful and ethical ways. Even if one’s own transactions are legitimate, supporting an ecosystem that facilitates impermissible activities can be problematic. Therefore, caution is paramount when dealing with any financial instrument that has a known association with such concerns.

Alternatives: Halal Wealth Preservation and Growth

Given the ethical concerns with Bitcoin, Muslims are encouraged to seek out alternatives that align with Islamic finance principles. These alternatives focus on real economic value, tangible assets, and ethical investments: Hardblock.com.au: An Assessment of its Core Offering

  • Gold and Silver: As historical Islamic currencies, gold and silver bullion (physical assets) are widely accepted as permissible stores of value and hedges against inflation. They represent tangible wealth.
  • Real Estate: Investing in income-generating properties or land is a permissible and often stable form of wealth accumulation. The asset is tangible, and the income derived is from a legitimate service (rent) or productive use.
  • Halal Equities/Funds: Investing in shares of companies that operate in permissible industries (e.g., technology, healthcare, manufacturing, ethical services) and comply with Sharia screening criteria (e.g., low debt, no involvement in alcohol, gambling, conventional finance, or entertainment). There are specific Sharia-compliant ETFs and managed funds available globally.
  • Commodities: Investing in essential commodities (e.g., agricultural products, non-speculative raw materials) that are bought and sold based on real supply and demand for their use value.
  • Ethical Businesses/Partnerships: Engaging in Mudarabah (profit-sharing) or Musharakah (joint venture) partnerships with businesses that adhere to Islamic ethical principles. This involves shared risk and reward in a real economic enterprise.
  • Takaful (Islamic Insurance): For protection and risk management, Takaful operates on principles of mutual cooperation and solidarity, avoiding riba and gharar found in conventional insurance.

These alternatives provide avenues for wealth preservation and growth that are grounded in tangible assets, productive activity, and ethical considerations, aligning with Islamic teachings.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

hardblock.com.au Logo
Skip / Close