Based on looking at the website, Creditsesame.com positions itself as a comprehensive platform for credit management, offering free credit scores, credit report summaries, and monitoring alerts.
However, it heavily promotes various financial products that involve interest-based transactions, such as credit cards, loans, and even a “credit builder” debit card system that relies on building credit history through reported payments—a mechanism often tied to conventional lending structures.
While transparency on data usage and security is mentioned, the core services revolve around credit scores and leveraging them for interest-bearing financial products.
Overall Review Summary:
- Primary Service: Free daily credit score, credit report summary, and credit monitoring.
- Key Offerings: Facilitates applications for credit cards, personal loans, auto loans, home loans, and insurance. Features a “Sesame Cash” prepaid debit card with a “credit builder” option.
- Ethical Stance Islamic Perspective: Highly problematic due to its pervasive promotion and integration with interest-based financial products Riba, which are strictly forbidden in Islam. The entire ecosystem it encourages, from credit cards to various types of loans, is fundamentally built on interest.
- Transparency: Provides detailed disclaimers regarding “Approval Odds” and fees associated with “Sesame Cash,” indicating a degree of transparency on specific product mechanics.
- Security: States use of 256-bit encryption and a policy against selling personal information to third parties.
- User Experience: Website is clean, user-friendly, and offers substantial educational content related to credit.
- Recommendation: Not recommended due to its direct involvement and promotion of Riba-based financial products.
The platform’s emphasis on acquiring credit cards and various types of loans, all of which typically involve interest, leads to a direct engagement with Riba.
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. |
Amazon.com:
Check Amazon for Creditsesame.com Review Latest Discussions & Reviews: |
Even the “credit builder” feature, which aims to improve credit scores, is designed to enable easier access to these interest-based products in the future.
For individuals seeking to manage their finances in an ethically permissible manner, this platform presents significant contradictions.
It’s crucial to understand that while a credit score itself is a metric, the means by which it is built and utilized through such platforms often involve impermissible transactions.
Therefore, while it may offer detailed credit information, the underlying mechanisms make it unsuitable for those adhering to Islamic financial principles.
Best Alternatives for Ethical Financial Management:
Instead of engaging with interest-based systems, individuals can pursue ethical financial management through principles that promote real economic growth, risk-sharing, and social welfare, devoid of Riba.
Here are some alternatives focused on ethical financial practices:
-
Islamic Banking & Finance Institutions
- Key Features: Offers Sharia-compliant financial products such as Murabaha cost-plus financing, Ijarah leasing, Musharakah partnership, and Takaful Islamic insurance. Focuses on asset-backed financing and risk-sharing.
- Price: Varies by product and institution, typically competitive with conventional banking, but structured differently to avoid interest.
- Pros: Adheres strictly to Islamic principles, promotes ethical investment and social responsibility, avoids Riba.
- Cons: Availability can be limited in some regions, product offerings may be less diverse than conventional banks.
-
Budgeting and Financial Planning Software e.g., You Need A Budget YNAB, Mint – though Mint is phasing out, alternatives like Empower formerly Personal Capital exist
- Key Features: Helps users track spending, create budgets, set financial goals, and manage debt ethically. Provides a clear overview of financial health.
- Price: Many offer free basic versions, while premium features might have monthly or annual subscriptions e.g., YNAB is around $14.99/month or $99/year.
- Pros: Empowers individuals to take control of their finances, promotes disciplined spending and saving, crucial for debt avoidance.
- Cons: Requires consistent user input and discipline to be effective, some premium features can be costly.
-
Debt Management & Counseling Services Look for non-profit credit counseling agencies, often accredited by NFCC
- Key Features: Provides guidance on managing and eliminating debt through ethical means, developing budgets, and negotiating with creditors without involving interest-based consolidation loans.
- Price: Often free for initial consultations, some services may have reasonable fees based on income for more extensive plans.
- Pros: Offers expert advice for those struggling with debt, focuses on sustainable solutions, can help avoid bankruptcy.
- Cons: Success depends on the individual’s commitment, some services might not be available in all areas.
-
Ethical Investment Platforms e.g., Wahed Invest, Amana Mutual Funds
- Key Features: Invests in Sharia-compliant portfolios, avoiding industries like alcohol, gambling, conventional finance, and unethical entertainment. Focuses on real economic activity and asset-backed investments.
- Price: Management fees vary, typically a percentage of assets under management e.g., 0.49% to 0.99% annually.
- Pros: Allows individuals to grow wealth while adhering to Islamic principles, promotes socially responsible investing.
- Cons: Returns may differ from conventional portfolios, fewer options available compared to mainstream investment platforms.
-
Financial Literacy Courses and Books
- Key Features: Provides foundational knowledge on personal finance, investment, and economic principles from an ethical perspective.
- Price: Varies from free online resources to paid courses and books.
- Pros: Empowers individuals with knowledge to make informed, ethical financial decisions, fosters financial independence.
- Cons: Requires self-discipline for learning, may not offer personalized advice.
-
Community-Based Lending & Saving Groups e.g., rotating savings and credit associations – ROSCAs
- Key Features: Informal groups where members contribute regularly to a common fund, which is then disbursed to one member in rotation, interest-free. Promotes mutual aid and communal support.
- Price: No fees, contributions are the capital.
- Pros: Interest-free access to lump sums, fosters community ties, simple and effective for saving and borrowing.
- Cons: Relies on trust among members, legal recourse can be limited if disputes arise.
-
Digital Cash Management Platforms e.g., Wise, formerly TransferWise for international transfers, or simple high-yield savings accounts from ethical banks if available
- Key Features: Focus on transparent, low-cost money transfers and cash management without involving credit or interest-bearing loans. Some platforms offer multi-currency accounts.
- Price: Transaction fees for transfers, but often lower than traditional banks.
- Pros: Efficiently manages liquid assets, avoids interest-based products, promotes practical financial transactions.
- Cons: Not designed for credit building or loans, primarily for cash flow and transfers.
Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.
IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.
Understanding Creditsesame.com: A Deep Dive into Its Offerings
Creditsesame.com positions itself as a central hub for credit management, promising users free access to their credit scores, report summaries, and monitoring alerts.
This approach aims to empower individuals with information about their financial standing.
However, a closer look reveals that the platform’s utility largely revolves around facilitating engagement with conventional financial products, many of which operate on interest-based models.
Creditsesame.com Review & First Look
Upon first glance, Creditsesame.com presents a sleek, user-friendly interface that emphasizes immediate access to credit information.
The site’s primary call to action is to “Get your credit score daily when you sign up for FREE,” highlighting its no-cost entry point. Kinkmen.com Review
This free access to credit scores and reports is a significant draw for many.
- Initial Impression: The website is well-designed and easy to navigate, with clear calls to action. It immediately conveys a sense of empowerment through financial information.
- Core Promise: Providing users with “100% free” access to their credit score and factors impacting it. This aligns with the common consumer need to understand their financial health.
- Subtle Implications: While the initial offering is free, the subsequent steps often involve encouraging users to apply for financial products like credit cards and loans, which are fundamentally linked to interest-based systems. This subtly shifts the focus from mere information to active participation in conventional finance.
- Security Claims: The site prominently features security assurances, stating it treats user data “as if it were our own,” uses “256-bit encryption,” and “does not sell your personal info to third parties.” These are crucial claims for any financial platform and build initial trust.
Creditsesame.com Pros & Cons Focus on Cons due to Ethical Concerns
Given the ethical considerations from an Islamic perspective, a balanced “Pros & Cons” list for Creditsesame.com needs to heavily emphasize the downsides related to its engagement with interest Riba.
- Free Credit Information: The primary “pro” from a purely informational standpoint is that Creditsesame.com offers a free credit score, credit report summary, and monitoring alerts. This allows users to track changes and understand basic credit factors without direct cost. For instance, TransUnion, a major credit bureau, integrates Credit Sesame’s platform for customer experience, indicating a baseline level of data reliability.
- Educational Resources: The site provides a substantial “Learn” section and a blog “Sesame Speaks” with articles on understanding credit scores, improving credit, and how various financial products work. This commitment to financial literacy is generally positive.
- User Testimonials and Ratings: The homepage features numerous positive customer testimonials and an average rating of 4.5/5 based on 564K reviews, suggesting a broad user base with generally positive experiences regarding the usability and perceived benefits of the service.
However, the “cons” are far more significant when viewed through an ethical lens:
- Pervasive Promotion of Riba-Based Products: This is the most critical drawback. Creditsesame.com is designed to guide users towards credit cards, personal loans, auto loans, and home loans—all of which are inherently interest-bearing in the conventional financial system. The platform explicitly states it helps users “Find credit card offers with a high chance of approval” and “See what your credit score can unlock for you” regarding loans. This directly encourages engagement with Riba, which is strictly prohibited in Islamic finance.
- “Credit Builder” Mechanism Relies on Debt and Interest: The “Sesame Cash” prepaid debit card and its “credit builder” feature, while marketed as a way to build credit without a credit check, ultimately involves creating a virtual secured credit card. As explained in their fine print: “Your debit card purchases are then added up to create a balance on your virtual secured credit card. As you make these purchases, an amount equal to the balance on your virtual secured credit card is also set aside… to ensure you can make timely payments… allowing you to build a positive payment history.” This system, by its very nature, is designed to integrate users into the conventional credit system, which is intrinsically linked to debt and interest. Even if interest is not charged on the secured card directly, the purpose of building this credit history is to gain access to future interest-bearing products.
- Encourages Dependence on Conventional Credit System: The entire premise of Creditsesame.com is to help users improve their “credit score” so they can “get the things you want most” through conventional financing. This reinforces a reliance on a system that is ethically problematic, rather than promoting self-sufficiency, debt avoidance, and interest-free financial practices.
- Fees for “Credit Builder” Service: While many services are “free,” the “Sesame Cash” credit builder has a “Monthly Fee” of $9.99 and a “$3 monthly inactivity fee,” though these can be waived under specific conditions e.g., depositing $500 monthly via direct deposit or spending $1,000. This indicates that the “free” aspect often has conditions that push users towards certain financial behaviors or lead to charges.
- Insurance Promotion: The platform also promotes various types of insurance, including home and life insurance. While insurance itself isn’t forbidden, conventional insurance models often involve elements of gharar excessive uncertainty and riba interest in their investment and operational structures, making Takaful Islamic cooperative insurance the preferred ethical alternative.
Creditsesame.com Pricing
Creditsesame.com heavily markets itself as “100% free” for its core credit monitoring services, and this appears to be largely true for the basic features.
However, as noted, there are nuances, particularly with its “Sesame Cash” product. Goliathautotransport.com Review
- Free Core Services:
- Daily credit score: Provided free of charge.
- Sesame Grade: A proprietary letter-grade assessment of credit health, also free.
- Credit report summary: Available for free.
- Credit monitoring alerts: Free notifications about changes to your credit profile.
- “Sesame Cash” Fees: While the prepaid debit card itself might be advertised as free to open, the “credit builder” feature comes with fees:
- $9.99 Monthly Fee: This fee can be waived if a user deposits $500 into their account via direct deposit or spends $1,000 each month with their Sesame Cash card.
- $3 Monthly Inactivity Fee: This fee can be waived if there is money movement or a purchase made with the account at least once within a 30-day rolling period.
- Waiver Period: As a courtesy, these fees are waived for the first 30 days of account opening.
- Additional Fees: International and out-of-network cash withdrawal fees, and third-party cash deposit fees may also apply, similar to other prepaid debit cards.
The business model appears to be freemium, where the “free” services attract users, and then the platform monetizes through referral fees from financial institutions for credit card and loan applications that users initiate through their site.
The “Sesame Cash” product also offers a direct revenue stream through its monthly fees if waiver conditions are not met.
This structure means that while direct payment for credit scores is avoided, the platform’s profitability is linked to the very financial instruments that are ethically problematic.
Creditsesame.com vs. Alternatives
Comparing Creditsesame.com with alternatives reveals different approaches to financial management, particularly highlighting the ethical divide.
-
Vs. Other Free Credit Score Providers e.g., Credit Karma, Experian Free Credit Report: Unifire.ai Review
- Similarities: Like Creditsesame.com, platforms such as Credit Karma offer free credit scores and reports often from different bureaus and similarly derive revenue from recommending financial products. Experian also offers a free credit score and report directly.
- Differences: The core ethical concern remains the same: all these platforms are deeply embedded in the conventional, interest-based financial system. While they provide useful data, their underlying business model often encourages engaging in Riba.
- Ethical Stance: From an Islamic perspective, all these conventional credit monitoring sites face the same fundamental issue of promoting and enabling interest-based transactions.
-
Vs. Ethical Financial Planning & Budgeting Tools e.g., You Need A Budget YNAB, Empower:
- Differences: These tools focus on managing your existing money and avoiding debt, rather than obtaining new credit. YNAB, for example, emphasizes “giving every dollar a job” and breaking the paycheck-to-paycheck cycle. Empower formerly Personal Capital offers comprehensive financial tracking, retirement planning, and investment analysis though users must be mindful of investment choices to ensure they are Sharia-compliant.
- Ethical Stance: These tools are generally neutral or positive from an Islamic perspective, as they promote financial discipline, saving, and debt avoidance. They do not actively push users towards interest-bearing products. Their utility lies in empowering users to manage their cash flow and assets responsibly, aligning with principles of frugality and wise stewardship.
-
Vs. Islamic Finance Institutions & Halal Investment Platforms:
- Fundamental Difference: This is where the starkest contrast lies. Islamic banks and investment platforms like Wahed Invest operate entirely without interest. They utilize Sharia-compliant contracts Murabaha, Ijarah, Musharakah for financing and only invest in ethically permissible industries.
- Ethical Stance: These are the preferred alternatives for Muslims as they align fully with Islamic financial principles, promoting justice, risk-sharing, and avoiding Riba. They offer a completely different paradigm for managing finances, focusing on real economic transactions rather than debt-based growth.
In essence, while Creditsesame.com offers a free window into the conventional credit system, its pervasive ties to interest-based products make it a problematic choice for those committed to Islamic financial ethics.
Alternatives that promote ethical money management, budgeting, and interest-free financing are vastly superior for achieving financial well-being without compromising faith.
Navigating the Conventional Credit Landscape: Implications for Ethical Finance
Understanding credit scores and reports is often presented as a cornerstone of financial literacy in the Western world. Newswirejet.com Review
Understanding the Credit Score System’s Ethical Challenges
The conventional credit score system, exemplified by FICO and VantageScore models, was developed to assess a borrower’s creditworthiness.
Lenders use these scores to determine the likelihood of repayment and, crucially, to set interest rates on loans and credit cards.
This directly ties the credit score to the concept of Riba.
- Purpose of Credit Scores: A credit score is a numerical representation of a person’s credit risk, calculated based on their credit history. This history includes payment punctuality, amounts owed, length of credit history, new credit, and credit mix.
- Integral to Interest-Based Lending: The higher your credit score, the better the interest rates you typically qualify for. This direct correlation means that improving one’s credit score through conventional means ultimately serves to facilitate engagement with lower-cost Riba. Even if a Muslim seeks a loan for a necessity, the entire system is predicated on interest, making it difficult to navigate without compromise.
- Building Credit History: The very act of “building credit” often involves taking on debt, such as credit cards or loans, and making consistent payments. This process of using interest-bearing instruments to establish a credit history is ethically fraught. For example, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau CFPB often details how credit scores are used to grant access to various financial products, inherently tying them to interest-based transactions Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
- The “Necessity” Argument: While some might argue that a good credit score is a necessity for housing or essential services in a conventional economy, the Islamic stance is to seek permissible alternatives wherever possible. If no halal alternative exists and a dire necessity arises, it becomes a complex issue, but the general principle is to avoid Riba.
The Role of Credit Sesame in Promoting Conventional Finance
Creditsesame.com is designed to integrate users more deeply into the conventional financial system.
By providing tools to monitor and ostensibly improve credit scores, it paves the way for greater participation in interest-based transactions. Bmipay.org Review
- Facilitating Access to Riba: The platform’s promotion of credit cards, auto loans, home loans, and personal loans, often with “high chance of approval” based on a user’s credit profile, directly links users to interest-bearing products. This is not merely an informational service. it’s a matchmaking service for conventional lenders.
- “Credit Builder” as a Gateway: The “Sesame Cash” credit builder feature, while appearing to offer a low-risk way to build credit, is ultimately about creating a payment history for a secured credit card. This history is then reported to credit bureaus, making it easier for users to obtain unsecured credit cards and loans in the future, which are nearly always interest-based. It’s a stepping stone into a system predicated on Riba.
- Monetization Strategy: Creditsesame.com’s business model relies on affiliate commissions from financial institutions when users apply for and obtain credit products through their platform. This means their financial incentive is directly tied to encouraging users to engage in interest-based borrowing. In 2021, the credit card market saw over $114 billion in interest charges alone in the U.S. Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Platforms like Credit Sesame help feed into this cycle.
How to Cancel Creditsesame.com Subscription if applicable
While Creditsesame.com advertises its core credit monitoring services as “100% free,” users might encounter situations where they want to terminate their relationship with the platform, especially if they’ve signed up for services like “Sesame Cash” that carry potential fees.
The primary concern from an ethical standpoint is to disengage from any platform that actively promotes Riba.
- No Traditional “Subscription” for Free Services: For the basic free credit score and monitoring services, there isn’t a “subscription” in the traditional sense that requires cancellation. Users generally just stop using the service or log out.
- Cancelling “Sesame Cash” if enrolled: If a user has enrolled in the “Sesame Cash” prepaid debit card and its credit builder feature, there would be a process to close that account to avoid any potential monthly or inactivity fees.
- Check the Terms of Service: The first step is always to refer to the “Sesame Cash Cardholder Agreement” for the official termination procedure. This document, usually found in the legal section of their website or within the app, will outline the exact steps.
- Contact Customer Support: Typically, closing a financial account like a prepaid debit card requires contacting the customer support of Credit Sesame or the issuing bank Community Federal Savings Bank for Sesame Cash. This can usually be done via phone, email, or a secure message within the app.
- Withdraw Funds: Before closing, ensure all funds are withdrawn from the Sesame Cash account.
- Confirm Account Closure: Always request confirmation of account closure in writing email or a message with a case number to ensure the account is fully terminated and no future fees are incurred.
Avoiding Financial Entanglements: A Path Forward
For individuals committed to ethical finance, the emphasis should be on avoiding debt entirely, especially interest-bearing loans.
- Prioritize Saving and Budgeting: Develop strong financial discipline through rigorous budgeting and consistent saving. Tools like You Need A Budget YNAB or simple spreadsheets can be invaluable. The average U.S. household carried over $100,000 in debt across various categories in 2023, excluding mortgages Source: Experian. A focus on saving can significantly reduce this burden.
- Explore Halal Financing Options: For necessary large purchases like homes or vehicles, seek out bona fide Islamic financial institutions that offer Sharia-compliant alternatives to conventional loans, such as Murabaha cost-plus financing or Ijarah leasing. These models involve asset ownership and sales, not interest on borrowed money. The global Islamic finance industry was estimated to be worth over $4 trillion in 2022, demonstrating a growing number of available ethical options Source: Thomson Reuters Islamic Finance Development Report.
- Build a Cash Economy: Focus on using cash or debit for purchases and building a strong financial position through real assets rather than through a credit score built on debt. This aligns with the Islamic economic principle of avoiding speculative and interest-based transactions.
- Utilize Ethical Investment: Instead of relying on conventional credit to acquire assets, consider building wealth through Sharia-compliant investments that grow through real economic activity. This includes halal stocks, sukuk Islamic bonds, and ethically screened mutual funds.
Ultimately, while platforms like Creditsesame.com offer a window into the conventional financial system, their fundamental reliance on Riba-based products makes them unsuitable for those adhering to Islamic financial principles.
The ethical path involves active avoidance of interest, rigorous financial discipline, and a concerted effort to utilize Sharia-compliant alternatives whenever possible. Carfridge.alpicool.com Review
FAQ
What is Creditsesame.com?
Creditsesame.com is an online platform that provides users with free access to their credit score, credit report summaries, and credit monitoring alerts, aiming to help them understand and manage their credit health.
Is Creditsesame.com really free?
Yes, Creditsesame.com offers its core credit score and monitoring services for free.
However, certain additional features, like the “Sesame Cash” credit builder debit card, may incur monthly or inactivity fees unless specific waiver conditions are met.
How does Creditsesame.com make money if it’s free?
Creditsesame.com primarily earns revenue through referral fees from financial institutions when users apply for credit cards, loans, or other financial products that are recommended on the platform.
It also earns revenue from fees associated with its “Sesame Cash” product. Sirdar.com Review
Is Creditsesame.com legitimate?
Yes, Creditsesame.com is a legitimate company that has been operating since 2010 and is integrated with major credit bureaus like TransUnion. It provides real credit data and services.
How often does Creditsesame.com update my credit score?
Creditsesame.com states that it updates your credit score daily, allowing users to see their score and any changes frequently.
Does checking my credit score on Creditsesame.com hurt my credit?
No, checking your credit score on Creditsesame.com is considered a “soft inquiry” and does not negatively impact your credit score.
What is the “Sesame Grade” on Creditsesame.com?
The “Sesame Grade” is a proprietary grading system developed by Creditsesame.com that provides a clear letter grade A-F based on five major factors impacting your credit score, aiming to make it easier to understand what needs attention.
What is “Sesame Cash” and its credit builder feature?
“Sesame Cash” is a prepaid debit card offered by Creditsesame.com. Clario.co Review
Its “credit builder” feature allows users to build credit history by creating a virtual secured credit card linked to their debit purchases, with payments reported to credit bureaus.
Does Creditsesame.com offer loans or credit cards directly?
No, Creditsesame.com does not offer loans or credit cards directly.
Instead, it acts as a marketplace, showing users offers from third-party lenders and credit card issuers based on their credit profile.
Is Creditsesame.com safe for my personal information?
Creditsesame.com claims to protect user data with 256-bit encryption and states that it does not sell personal information to third parties, aiming to ensure security and privacy.
Can I get my full credit report from Creditsesame.com?
Creditsesame.com provides a “credit report summary,” which highlights key factors and sections of your credit report. Cvresumenest.com Review
For a full, detailed credit report, you typically need to go directly to one of the three major credit bureaus Equifax, Experian, TransUnion or use AnnualCreditReport.com.
How do I cancel my Creditsesame.com account?
For the free services, there isn’t a traditional “subscription” to cancel. you can simply stop using the platform.
If you have a “Sesame Cash” account, you would need to contact their customer support or the issuing bank Community Federal Savings Bank to formally close the account and avoid any associated fees.
What credit bureau does Creditsesame.com use?
Creditsesame.com primarily uses data from TransUnion to provide credit scores and reports.
Are the credit offers on Creditsesame.com guaranteed for approval?
No, the credit offers presented on Creditsesame.com, including those with a “high chance of approval,” are not guaranteed. Warrenevans.com Review
The platform’s “Approval Odds” are estimates, and final approval is always at the discretion of the lender based on their full underwriting criteria.
Does Creditsesame.com help with debt management?
Creditsesame.com provides educational content and insights into factors affecting your credit, which can indirectly help with debt understanding.
However, it does not offer direct debt management plans or counseling.
Its focus is on credit monitoring and product recommendations.
Is using Creditsesame.com permissible in Islam?
From an Islamic perspective, Creditsesame.com is problematic because its core utility and monetization model are deeply intertwined with promoting and facilitating interest-based financial products like credit cards and various types of loans Riba, which are strictly prohibited in Islam. Alphafemme.com Review
What are some ethical alternatives to Creditsesame.com for financial management?
Ethical alternatives include using budgeting and financial planning software e.g., YNAB, engaging with Islamic banking and finance institutions for Sharia-compliant products, seeking non-profit debt counseling for ethical debt management, and investing through halal investment platforms.
Does Creditsesame.com sell my data?
Creditsesame.com explicitly states on its homepage that it “does not sell your personal info to third parties.”
Can Creditsesame.com help me improve my credit score?
Creditsesame.com provides personalized actions and insights into what’s impacting your score, and its “Sesame Cash” credit builder feature is designed to help users build credit history.
However, credit score improvement is not guaranteed and depends on various financial habits.
Why is engagement with interest-based financial products discouraged in Islam?
Engagement with interest Riba is prohibited in Islam because it is seen as an exploitative practice that generates wealth without real economic activity, concentrates wealth, and leads to injustice and instability, contrary to the principles of equitable and fair economic transactions. Nforcd.com Review
Leave a Reply