ClickMoat Pros & Cons

Alright, let’s talk about the good stuff and the not-so-good stuff with ClickMoat, based on what users are saying. No tool is perfect, and it’s always good to get a balanced view.

🚨 Lifetime Deal Alert: Available Now on AppSumo! ⏳ Don’t Miss Out

The Good Stuff (Pros)

• Real Savings on Ad Spend: This is a big one. Many users report significant savings on their ad budget, with some seeing as much as 30% reduction by blocking fraudulent clicks. That’s money back in your pocket that would have been wasted.
• Effective Click Fraud Protection: Users generally appreciate its ability to detect and block fraudulent clicks effectively. It uses AI, which is designed to catch even subtle patterns that might go unnoticed by manual checks.
• User-Friendly Setup: People often mention that ClickMoat is pretty straightforward to set up. You typically just need to add a tracking code to your website, and then you’re good to go.
• Responsive Customer Support: This is a consistent positive. Users frequently praise the support team for being responsive, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful, often available through platforms like Slack. This kind of direct and quick support can be a huge relief when you’re dealing with technical issues.
• Detailed Insights and Analytics: You get clear, easy-to-understand reports that show you where fraud is coming from, how much money you’re saving, and even which keywords or locations are affected. This data helps you optimize your campaigns better.
• Helps with Google Ads Refunds: ClickMoat provides the necessary reports and even assistance to help you claim refunds from Google for fraudulent clicks, which is a big bonus.
• AI-Powered and Learning: The fact that its AI is constantly learning and adapting to new fraud tactics is a huge plus, meaning its protection should theoretically get better over time.
• Customizable Protection Rules: The ability to set your own rules for click thresholds, VPN blocking, and device ID tracking gives you a lot of control over your ad protection.

The Not-So-Good Stuff (Cons)

• Initial Setup Issues (Reported by some): While many find it easy to set up, there have been instances where the tracking code caused issues, like landing pages not loading for new visitors. This could lead to a significant loss of leads and wasted ad spend if not caught immediately. The ClickMoat team has acknowledged these issues and worked to resolve them, attributing some to API package updates.
• “Budget Saved” Exaggeration (Debated by some on Reddit): Some users, particularly in broader discussions about click fraud tools, express skepticism that the “budget saved” figures are always accurate or represent true incremental value. They argue that Google’s own fraud detection is often efficient, and some click fraud tools might overstate their impact.
• Blocking After the Initial Click: It’s important to understand that ClickMoat, like many similar tools, operates after the initial ad click has been counted by Google. It blocks subsequent fraudulent activity, but the first click is still registered. While this prevents further wasted budget from that source, some users wish it could prevent the initial click entirely (though this is often technically impossible).
• Early Stages/Bugs (User feedback): While praised for its effectiveness, some users have noted that the tool is still in its “early stages” and may have some bugs or processes that need further development. However, they also commend the team for being highly responsive to these issues.
• Potential for Legitimate Clicks to be Flagged: In scenarios where landing pages might briefly not load, there’s a concern that legitimate users attempting to reload the page could be marked as suspicious and blocked. The team has stated they are investigating such feedback.
• Reliance on IP Blocking Effectiveness (Broader industry discussion): Some Reddit discussions on click fraud tools suggest that IP-based blocking can be ineffective against sophisticated click fraud that uses unique or constantly changing IP addresses (like residential proxy services). While ClickMoat uses more than just IP blocking (like AI and device ID), this is a general concern within the industry.
• Slack-based support preference: One user mentioned they weren’t a fan of Slack for support, finding it somewhat disjointed, though acknowledging support was still effective.

Overall, ClickMoat seems to be a powerful tool for many, especially for those who are actively managing Google Ads and are concerned about wasted spend. Its strengths lie in its AI-powered detection, customizable rules, and strong customer support. However, like any software, it’s not without its challenges, and potential users should be aware of the reported issues and general industry discussions around click fraud prevention.

Read more about ClickMoat Review:
ClickMoat Review & First Look
How Does ClickMoat Work?
ClickMoat Features