Cinkadv.com Review 1 by Partners

Cinkadv.com Review

Updated on

Based on looking at the website, Cinkadv.com appears to be a platform that requires careful consideration.

The lack of detailed information regarding its services and operational transparency raises significant concerns for potential users.

Overall Review Summary:

  • Trustworthiness: Low
  • Transparency: Very Low
  • Ethical Compliance: Unclear due to lack of information
  • Security: Unknown
  • Recommendation: Not Recommended

The website’s minimalist approach, while sometimes seen as modern, in this context translates to a concerning scarcity of essential details.

Users are left without clear understanding of what Cinkadv.com offers, how it operates, or who is behind it.

0.0
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Amazon.com: Check Amazon for Cinkadv.com Review
Latest Discussions & Reviews:

This absence of critical information often signals potential risks and makes it difficult to assess the platform’s legitimacy or ethical standing.

For any online service, especially one that might involve personal data or transactions, a lack of transparency is a major red flag.

Best Alternatives for Ethical Online Engagement General Ethical Online Services:

  • ProtonMail

    • Key Features: End-to-end encrypted email, secure calendar, VPN services. Focus on privacy and security.
    • Average Price: Free basic plan, paid plans starting around $4.99/month.
    • Pros: Strong encryption, based in Switzerland strong privacy laws, no personal data logging, open-source.
    • Cons: Free plan has limited storage, some features require paid subscription.
  • DuckDuckGo

    • Key Features: Privacy-focused search engine, blocks ad trackers, provides app and browser extensions for enhanced privacy.
    • Average Price: Free.
    • Pros: Does not track search history or IP address, clean interface, anonymous search.
    • Cons: Search results might be less personalized which is a pro for privacy but can be a con for convenience for some.
  • Startpage

    • Key Features: Private search engine using Google’s results but without tracking, anonymous view proxy.
    • Pros: Combines Google’s search power with strong privacy, no tracking, anonymous browsing feature.
    • Cons: Can be slightly slower due to proxy, anonymous view might not work on all sites.
  • Nextcloud

    • Key Features: Self-hosted productivity platform, file synchronization, document editing, calendar, contacts, video calls.
    • Average Price: Free self-hosted, paid enterprise options.
    • Pros: Full control over your data, open-source, highly customizable, strong privacy features.
    • Cons: Requires technical knowledge for self-hosting, setup time.
  • Jitsi Meet

    • Key Features: Open-source, encrypted video conferencing, no account needed for basic use.
    • Pros: Easy to use, no sign-up required, strong privacy features, good for quick meetings.
    • Cons: Can be resource-intensive, performance might vary with large groups.
  • Signal

    • Key Features: End-to-end encrypted messaging, voice, and video calls.
    • Pros: Gold standard for privacy, open-source, used by journalists and privacy advocates, no data collection.
    • Cons: Requires phone number for registration, less popular than other messaging apps, so fewer contacts might be on it.
  • VeraCrypt

    • Key Features: Free open-source disk encryption software, creates encrypted virtual disk.
    • Pros: Strong encryption algorithms, widely audited, protects sensitive data, cross-platform.
    • Cons: Requires some technical understanding to use effectively, forgotten passwords mean lost data.

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

Table of Contents

Cinkadv.com Review & First Look

Initial Impressions of Cinkadv.com

The first impression is one of mystery, bordering on suspicion. There’s no tagline, no mission statement, no engaging visuals, and most importantly, no apparent value proposition. It’s just… there. This minimalistic approach could be interpreted as modern or sleek by some, but for a service-oriented website, it’s detrimental. Think of it like this: would you trust a business that has no visible sign, no explanation of its offerings, and just a door? Probably not. The digital equivalent applies here. According to consumer behavior data, 94% of consumers will leave a website if it lacks information about the product or service. Cinkadv.com’s design choice, or lack thereof, directly undermines its ability to build trust with visitors.

Missing Essential Website Elements

A legitimate and trustworthy website typically includes several non-negotiable elements.

Cinkadv.com is conspicuously missing almost all of them. Here’s a quick rundown of what’s absent:

  • No ‘About Us’ Page: This is foundational. Users want to know who is behind the service, their mission, and their values.
  • No ‘Contact Us’ Information: There’s no email, phone number, physical address, or even a contact form. This makes it impossible to reach out for support or inquiries, indicating a severe lack of accountability.
  • No Service Description: What does Cinkadv.com do? Is it a product, a service, an informational site? There is literally no explanation.
  • No Terms of Service or Privacy Policy: These legal documents are crucial for outlining user rights, data handling practices, and service agreements. Their absence is a massive legal and ethical red flag. In many jurisdictions, this is a legal requirement for any website collecting data or offering services.
  • No FAQs: A common section for addressing user queries and demonstrating an understanding of customer needs.
  • No Testimonials or Case Studies: While not mandatory, their absence further compounds the lack of credibility.

This extensive list of missing elements paints a clear picture: Cinkadv.com does not appear to be a legitimate, professionally operated online service.

Cinkadv.com Cons & Ethical Considerations

Lack of Transparency and Accountability

The most prominent con of Cinkadv.com is its utter lack of transparency. This isn’t just about minor details. it’s about fundamental information that any user would expect to find on a legitimate website. There is no “About Us” section, no clear “Contact Us” page, and absolutely no explanation of what the website does. This creates an environment of ambiguity that is highly problematic. Somethingdifferent.scot Review

  • No Visible Ownership Information: Who operates Cinkadv.com? Is it an individual, a company, a collective? Without this, there’s no entity to hold accountable for any potential issues. According to a study by the Online Trust Alliance, websites with clear ownership and contact information are perceived as significantly more trustworthy.
  • Absence of Legal Disclosures: Crucially, there are no readily available Terms of Service or Privacy Policy. These documents are not just legal niceties. they are fundamental ethical agreements between a website and its users. They detail how user data is collected, stored, and used, as well as the rights and responsibilities of both parties. Their absence is a severe breach of ethical web practices and a potential legal liability. In the European Union, for example, the GDPR mandates clear and comprehensive privacy policies for any website handling user data.
  • No Operational Details: Users cannot discern the operational model of Cinkadv.com. Is it a service, a product, a data collection site? This obscurity makes it impossible to assess its purpose or its ethical implications.

Potential for Misuse or Malicious Intent

When a website lacks transparency to this degree, it opens the door to the potential for misuse or even malicious activities.

While it’s impossible to definitively state Cinkadv.com is malicious without deeper analysis, the absence of basic information creates an environment where such activities could thrive undetected.

  • Phishing Risk: Websites with minimal content and no clear purpose can sometimes be precursors to phishing attempts, where users are tricked into divulging sensitive information.
  • Malware Distribution: Without a clear and legitimate service, there’s always a risk that such sites could be used to host or distribute malware, though this is speculative without further investigation.
  • Data Exploitation: If the site were to collect any user data without a privacy policy, there’s no legal framework or ethical guideline preventing the exploitation or sale of that data. The cost of data breaches globally is estimated to be over $4 million per incident, underscoring the importance of robust data protection policies.
  • Scam Potential: The lack of a clear service offering makes it difficult to ascertain if Cinkadv.com is a legitimate business or merely a front for a scam. Without any verifiable information, users are vulnerable.

The inherent risks associated with such a non-transparent website make it a significant concern for anyone prioritizing online safety and ethical engagement.

Cinkadv.com Alternatives

Given the significant lack of transparency and information on Cinkadv.com, it’s crucial to explore reliable and ethical alternatives for a wide range of online needs.

When a website is opaque, it creates an environment ripe for uncertainty and potential issues, making it unsuitable for any interaction. Rafflewinners.uk Review

Instead of risking engagement with such a platform, focusing on established, transparent, and trustworthy online services is always the wiser choice.

The alternatives provided below are chosen for their strong reputation, clear operational practices, and commitment to user experience and security.

They cover various aspects of online interaction, from shopping to information gathering, ensuring users can find reliable platforms for their needs.

Ethical Online Shopping Platforms

For purchasing goods and services online, transparency, secure transactions, and ethical practices are paramount.

  • Amazon

    Amazon Shutterstore.com Review

    • Key Features: Vast selection of products across numerous categories, global shipping, customer reviews, secure payment gateways.
    • Pros: Enormous product range, competitive pricing, reliable shipping, robust customer service, clear return policies.
    • Cons: Can be overwhelming due to size, concerns about worker conditions for some, encourages consumption.
    • Note: While a massive marketplace, Amazon’s transparency in terms of product listings and customer reviews is generally high. Users can easily find product descriptions, seller information, and often detailed reviews, which are crucial for informed purchasing.
  • Etsy

    • Key Features: Focus on handmade, vintage, and unique items, supports small businesses and artisans, community-driven marketplace.
    • Pros: Unique products, supports independent creators, strong community aspect, transparent seller profiles.
    • Cons: Prices can be higher due to custom nature, shipping times vary by seller.
    • Note: Etsy thrives on seller transparency, with clear shop policies, contact information for individual sellers, and direct messaging capabilities, fostering trust between buyers and creators.

Secure and Private Communication Platforms

When it comes to communication, privacy, and security are non-negotiable.

These alternatives prioritize user data protection.

*   Key Features: End-to-end encrypted messaging, voice, and video calls. open-source, no data collection.
*   Pros: Industry-leading encryption, highly secure, transparent code, free to use.
*   Cons: Requires a phone number for registration, less widespread adoption than mainstream messaging apps.
*   Note: Signal is renowned for its transparency, with its protocol being open-source and regularly audited, giving users full confidence in its security and privacy claims.

*   Key Features: Encrypted email service, based in Switzerland, privacy-focused, zero-access encryption.
*   Pros: Strong privacy laws, easy-to-use interface, free tier available, integrated VPN option.
*   Cons: Limited storage on free plan, some advanced features require paid subscription.
*   Note: ProtonMail is built on principles of transparency and privacy, clearly outlining its encryption methods and legal protections, offering a stark contrast to opaque services.

Reliable Information and Research Resources

For credible information, sources that prioritize accuracy, citations, and editorial oversight are essential. C9pg.com Review

  • Wikipedia

    • Key Features: Collaborative, open-source encyclopedia, vast range of topics, extensive citations.
    • Pros: Free, widely accessible, constantly updated, good starting point for research.
    • Cons: Information can sometimes be biased or inaccurate though typically self-correcting, not a primary source for academic research.
    • Note: Wikipedia’s transparency comes from its collaborative editing model and the requirement for verifiable citations, allowing users to trace information back to its source.
  • Academic Journals & Databases e.g., Google Scholar

    • Key Features: Access to peer-reviewed scholarly literature, research papers, and academic articles.
    • Pros: High level of credibility, in-depth analysis, reliable data.
    • Cons: Can be behind paywalls, complex terminology, not suitable for general readers.
    • Note: These platforms represent the pinnacle of transparency in information, with rigorous peer-review processes ensuring accuracy, methodology, and ethical data collection are clearly articulated.

Cloud Storage and Productivity Tools

For managing documents and collaborating, secure and transparent cloud services are critical.

*   Key Features: Self-hosted file synchronization and sharing platform, open-source, full control over data.
*   Pros: Maximum privacy and control, customizable, feature-rich calendar, contacts, office suite integration.
*   Cons: Requires technical knowledge for setup and maintenance, not a managed service.
*   Note: Nextcloud is explicitly designed for transparency, allowing users to host their data on their own servers, eliminating concerns about third-party data handling.
  • LibreOffice
    • Key Features: Free and open-source office suite word processing, spreadsheets, presentations, databases.
    • Pros: Powerful, compatible with Microsoft Office formats, community support, free to use.
    • Cons: Interface might be less familiar to MS Office users, some compatibility issues with complex documents.
    • Note: As an open-source project, LibreOffice’s development is fully transparent, with its code publicly available for review, ensuring no hidden functionalities or data collection practices.

How to Avoid Unreliable Websites

Navigating the internet safely requires a keen eye and a strategic approach, especially when encountering websites like Cinkadv.com that offer little to no transparency. Recognizing red flags and adopting proactive measures can significantly reduce your risk of encountering scams, misinformation, or malicious content. It’s about building a robust digital literacy and developing a skepticism that serves as your first line of defense. Data from cybersecurity firms consistently shows that user vigilance is a critical factor in preventing online fraud, with an estimated 65% of cyberattacks preventable through user awareness and training.

Identifying Red Flags on a Website

Before you even consider interacting with a website, a quick check for these tell-tale signs can save you a lot of trouble. Larsa.org Review

  • Lack of Contact Information: A legitimate business will always provide clear ways to contact them—a physical address, phone number, email, or a comprehensive contact form. If these are absent or hard to find, proceed with extreme caution. Over 80% of online scams lack verifiable contact details.
  • Missing Legal Pages: Every professional website, especially those collecting data or engaging in transactions, must have easily accessible Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, and often a Refund/Return Policy. Absence of these pages is a significant legal and ethical breach.
  • Generic or Poor Quality Content: If the website’s text is riddled with grammatical errors, awkward phrasing, or seems copied and pasted from other sites, it’s a major red flag. Legitimate businesses invest in professional content.
  • Unusual Domain Names: Be wary of domain names that are overly long, contain strange character combinations, or mimic established brands with slight misspellings e.g., “amaz0n.com” instead of “amazon.com”.
  • No Information About “Who We Are”: The absence of an “About Us” page or any information about the company’s mission, history, or team members is a strong indicator of an untrustworthy site.
  • Overly Aggressive Pop-ups or Ads: While some sites use ads, excessive, intrusive, or difficult-to-close pop-ups, particularly those pushing suspicious downloads or surveys, are a sign of a potentially harmful site.
  • Suspicious Payment Methods: If a website only offers unconventional payment methods e.g., wire transfers to individuals, cryptocurrency only without clear explanation or lacks secure payment gateways look for “https://” in the URL and a padlock icon, be very cautious.

Tools and Practices for Website Verification

Beyond spotting red flags, employing specific tools and practices can further enhance your online safety.

Amazon

  • URL Checkers: Use online tools like Google Safe Browsing or VirusTotal to check if a URL has been reported for phishing, malware, or other malicious activities.
  • Whois Lookup: A Whois lookup tool can reveal registration details of a domain, including the owner’s contact information though often privacy protected, registration date, and expiration date. Very new domains for established-sounding businesses can be suspicious.
  • Online Reviews and Forums: Search for reviews of the website on independent review platforms e.g., Trustpilot or in relevant online forums. Be critical of reviews. look for consistent patterns rather than just a few positive or negative ones.
  • Verify SSL Certificate: Always check for “https://” at the beginning of the URL and a padlock icon in the browser’s address bar. This indicates that the website uses an SSL certificate to encrypt data transferred between your browser and the server. While not a guarantee of legitimacy, its absence is a major red flag.
  • Reverse Image Search: If a website uses generic or suspicious-looking images, especially for products, perform a reverse image search to see if the images are stock photos or stolen from other legitimate sites.
  • Browser Security Settings: Keep your web browser updated and ensure its security settings are enabled to block pop-ups, warn about suspicious sites, and manage cookies securely.

By systematically applying these verification methods, you can build a more robust defense against unreliable and potentially harmful websites, ensuring your online interactions are safer and more secure.

The Importance of Ethical Online Practices

Building Trust Through Transparency

Transparency is the cornerstone of ethical online engagement.

It means being open and honest about operations, intentions, and data handling. Lapizzeriagroup.com Review

  • Clear Information Disclosure: Ethical websites clearly state who they are, what services they offer, and how they operate. This includes easily accessible “About Us” pages, comprehensive service descriptions, and detailed contact information. This clarity helps users understand the context of their interaction.
  • Explicit Data Policies: A critical aspect of transparency is the explicit disclosure of data collection, storage, and usage practices through a well-articulated Privacy Policy. Users have a right to know what personal information is being gathered and how it will be utilized. Lack of such policies implies data exploitation or negligence.
  • Honest Communication: Ethical practices dictate honest communication about service limitations, pricing, and any potential risks. Misleading advertising or hidden fees are antithetical to transparency and erode user trust.

Protecting User Privacy and Data Security

The ethical imperative to protect user privacy and data security is paramount.

In an era of rampant data breaches, this responsibility cannot be overstated.

  • Strong Data Encryption: Websites should implement robust encryption protocols e.g., SSL/TLS, indicated by “https://” to protect data in transit. For sensitive data, encryption at rest is also essential. IBM Security’s 2023 Cost of a Data Breach Report found that data breaches cost companies an average of $4.45 million.
  • Minimizing Data Collection: Ethical practice dictates collecting only the data that is absolutely necessary for the provision of a service. Unnecessary data collection increases risk and is an overreach of user privacy.
  • User Control Over Data: Users should have control over their data, including the ability to access, modify, and delete their personal information. This empowers users and aligns with principles of data sovereignty.
  • Regular Security Audits: Ethical organizations regularly audit their systems for vulnerabilities and address security weaknesses promptly. This proactive approach minimizes the risk of breaches and demonstrates a commitment to user safety.

Promoting Accountability and Responsibility

Ethical online practices require websites and service providers to be accountable for their actions and responsible for the impact they have on users.

  • Clear Terms of Service: These documents establish the legal framework of the user-website relationship, outlining rights, responsibilities, and dispute resolution mechanisms. Their presence indicates a commitment to a fair and responsible engagement.
  • Effective Complaint Mechanisms: Users should have clear channels to report issues, provide feedback, or lodge complaints. A responsive customer support system is a hallmark of an ethical operation.
  • Adherence to Legal and Regulatory Standards: Ethical websites comply with relevant laws and regulations, including consumer protection laws, data privacy acts like GDPR, CCPA, and industry-specific guidelines. Non-compliance is a serious ethical and legal failing.
  • Consequences for Misconduct: True accountability means that there are consequences for unethical behavior or breaches of trust, whether through legal action, reputational damage, or industry sanctions.

By upholding these ethical tenets, online platforms can build lasting trust with their users, contributing to a safer, more reliable, and ultimately more beneficial internet experience for everyone.

The Dangers of Unidentified Online Services

Financial Risks and Scams

One of the most immediate dangers posed by unidentified online services is the potential for financial fraud and scams. Discounttyres.ie Review

  • Non-Delivery of Goods/Services: If you transact with a service that has no clear identity or contact information, there’s no recourse if you pay for a product or service that is never delivered. Funds sent are often unrecoverable.
  • Credit Card Fraud: Unscrupulous websites may be designed to collect credit card details for fraudulent purposes. Without proper security measures or a clear privacy policy, your financial information is highly vulnerable. According to the Nilson Report, global card fraud losses reached $32.04 billion in 2021.
  • Hidden Charges and Subscriptions: Some unidentified services might trick users into signing up for recurring charges or hidden subscriptions, which are extremely difficult to cancel without clear contact information.
  • Investment Scams: Such sites can masquerade as legitimate investment opportunities, promising high returns with low risk, only to disappear with investor funds. The anonymity allows perpetrators to avoid detection.

Data Privacy and Security Vulnerabilities

Beyond financial risks, unidentified services pose a severe threat to your personal data and overall digital security.

  • Personal Data Theft: Websites without clear privacy policies or secure infrastructure are prime targets for data theft. Any personal information you input, from your name and email to more sensitive details, could be compromised and used for identity theft or sold on the dark web.
  • Lack of Data Protection: Without a stated commitment to data protection, there’s no guarantee that your data is being handled securely, encrypted, or protected against unauthorized access. This can lead to serious privacy breaches.
  • Malware and Virus Distribution: Unidentified websites can be used as vectors for distributing malware, ransomware, or viruses. Simply visiting such a site or clicking on a deceptive link could infect your device. Approximately 32% of all cyberattacks involve malware, according to Verizon’s 2023 Data Breach Investigations Report.
  • Phishing Attacks: These sites can serve as fronts for sophisticated phishing operations, designed to trick you into revealing login credentials for other accounts e.g., banking, email, social media.

Reputational and Legal Exposure

Engaging with unidentified or unethical online services can also have indirect but significant consequences.

  • Association with Illicit Activities: If a service you interact with is later found to be involved in illegal or unethical activities, your association, however unwitting, could potentially expose you to reputational damage or even legal scrutiny.
  • Loss of Trust in Online Services: Repeated negative experiences with untrustworthy websites can lead to a general distrust of online services, making it harder for users to leverage legitimate and beneficial platforms.
  • Reinforcing Bad Practices: By engaging with opaque services, users inadvertently contribute to an environment where such practices can continue to thrive, making the internet less safe for everyone.

The message is clear: if an online service cannot identify itself or clearly articulate its purpose and policies, it is best to avoid it entirely. Your digital safety and peace of mind depend on making informed and cautious choices.

FAQ

What is Cinkadv.com?

Based on looking at the website, Cinkadv.com appears to be an online platform with a minimal and uninformative homepage, providing no clear description of its services, purpose, or ownership.

Is Cinkadv.com a legitimate website?

The legitimacy of Cinkadv.com is highly questionable due to the complete absence of essential information such as an “About Us” page, contact details, service descriptions, or legal policies like Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Flatsite.com Review

What are the main concerns about Cinkadv.com?

The main concerns about Cinkadv.com include its extreme lack of transparency, absence of legal and contact information, and the unclear nature of its purpose, which raises red flags regarding its trustworthiness and potential for misuse.

Does Cinkadv.com have a privacy policy?

No, Cinkadv.com does not appear to have a visible or accessible privacy policy on its homepage, which is a significant ethical and legal concern for any website.

Can I trust Cinkadv.com with my personal information?

No, it is strongly advised not to trust Cinkadv.com with any personal information due to its lack of transparency, security indicators, and clear data handling policies.

Are there any reviews for Cinkadv.com online?

As of current assessment, there are no readily available or prominent independent reviews for Cinkadv.com, which further contributes to its questionable status.

How can I contact Cinkadv.com?

Based on the website’s homepage, there are no visible contact details such as an email address, phone number, or contact form, making it impossible to directly contact Cinkadv.com. Helloskills.com Review

What kind of service is Cinkadv.com supposed to provide?

It is unclear what kind of service Cinkadv.com is supposed to provide, as its homepage offers no descriptive text, product listings, or service explanations.

Is it safe to visit Cinkadv.com?

While simply visiting the website might not immediately cause harm, interacting with it or providing any personal details is not recommended due to the strong indicators of an untrustworthy site.

What are the ethical concerns regarding Cinkadv.com?

The primary ethical concerns regarding Cinkadv.com revolve around its complete lack of transparency, failure to provide essential legal disclosures like a Privacy Policy, and its ambiguous nature, which undermines user trust and ethical online conduct.

What are some ethical alternatives to Cinkadv.com for online services?

Ethical alternatives for various online services include Amazon or Etsy for shopping, Signal or ProtonMail for secure communication, and Wikipedia or Google Scholar for information.

Amazon Vaultcapitalllc.com Review

Does Cinkadv.com have any identifiable owners or operators?

No, the website does not provide any information about its owners, operators, or the organization behind it, making it an unidentified online service.

Why is a lack of information a red flag for a website?

A lack of information is a significant red flag because legitimate businesses are transparent about their identity, services, policies, and how to contact them, fostering trust and accountability.

Should I avoid websites like Cinkadv.com?

Yes, it is highly recommended to avoid websites like Cinkadv.com that lack transparency, essential contact information, and clear service descriptions, as they often pose risks.

What is the risk of engaging with an unidentified online service?

The risks of engaging with an unidentified online service include financial fraud, personal data theft, exposure to malware, and a lack of recourse if issues arise.

How can I report a suspicious website like Cinkadv.com?

You can report suspicious websites to relevant authorities like the Federal Trade Commission FTC in the US or through browser security features e.g., Google Safe Browsing. Mytechvisor.com Review

What security features does Cinkadv.com have?

There is no information available on Cinkadv.com’s homepage to indicate what, if any, security features it employs, which is concerning for data protection.

Does Cinkadv.com collect user data?

Without a privacy policy, it is impossible to determine if or how Cinkadv.com collects user data.

However, any website you visit typically collects some basic data, and without a policy, you have no transparency.

Is Cinkadv.com associated with any known scams or fraudulent activities?

While a definitive link to known scams cannot be established without further investigation, the characteristics of Cinkadv.com extreme lack of transparency are commonly associated with scam or untrustworthy websites.

What steps can I take to protect myself from suspicious websites?

To protect yourself, always check for contact information, legal policies, look for “https://” in the URL, use URL checkers, read independent reviews, and trust your instincts if something feels off. Nft.third.place Review



Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *