Based on checking the website, 52memories.com offers a unique wedding gift service, transforming guest memories into personalized photo postcards delivered weekly to newlyweds for an entire year.
While the concept is novel, a closer look at the website’s offerings from an ethical perspective, particularly concerning transparency and long-term value, reveals areas for consideration.
Here’s an overall review summary:
- Service Concept: Transforms wedding guest photos and greetings into printed postcards, sent weekly for a year.
- Target Audience: Newlyweds, wedding guests looking for a unique gift.
- Ease of Use Website: Appears straightforward, with a clear four-step process for guests to create cards.
- Transparency: Lacks clear pricing details upfront on the main page, requiring navigation to a separate “Order now” section to see package costs. Specific data privacy practices are not immediately obvious.
- Customer Support: Offers an FAQ section and contact information, including an email for paper samples.
- Ethical Considerations: The service itself does not appear to involve any inherently impermissible elements. However, the lack of immediate pricing transparency on the main page could be a point of concern for some users seeking full disclosure upfront. The focus on sentimental value is positive, but the long-term archival method of these digital memories isn’t explicitly detailed.
- Overall Recommendation: While the concept is heartwarming, the immediate lack of pricing detail and in-depth privacy policy on the main page suggests a need for users to perform a deeper dive before committing. The service does not directly promote or engage in impermissible activities.
The idea of preserving wedding memories is undeniably beautiful, and 52memories.com attempts to do so in a tangible, weekly surprise format.
However, as discerning consumers, especially those who prioritize transparency and ethical conduct, we need to dig into the finer points.
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one. |
Amazon.com:
Check Amazon for 52memories.com Review Latest Discussions & Reviews: |
A website’s homepage should be a beacon of clarity, not a puzzle.
When key information like pricing is tucked away, it raises an eyebrow.
It’s not necessarily a red flag, but it signals that you need to invest a bit more time to get the full picture.
The service appears to be a creative way to cherish memories, but always remember to do your due diligence, especially when it comes to online services.
Here are some excellent alternatives for preserving memories and creating meaningful, ethical gifts:
- Artifact Uprising Photo Books:
- Key Features: High-quality custom photo books, layflat albums, softcover options, personalized designs. Focus on tangible, durable keepsakes.
- Average Price: Varies widely, from $20 for a softcover book to $300+ for a large, layflat album.
- Pros: Exceptional print quality, wide range of customization, environmentally conscious practices, lasting physical product for multiple memories in one place.
- Cons: Can be more expensive for premium options, requires user design effort.
- Mixbook Custom Photo Calendars:
- Key Features: Create personalized wall calendars, desk calendars, and planners with your photos and custom dates. Variety of themes and layouts.
- Average Price: $15 – $40, depending on size and customization.
- Pros: Practical, functional, and decorative. A new memory or theme for each month. Easy-to-use design tools.
- Cons: Limited to a one-year cycle, physical product only.
- Shutterfly Custom Photo Albums:
- Key Features: Wide array of photo album styles, sizes, and cover options. User-friendly design interface for drag-and-drop customization.
- Average Price: $30 – $150, depending on size, pages, and cover material.
- Pros: Reputable brand, frequent discounts, good range of options, preserves many memories in one volume.
- Cons: Print quality can sometimes vary, upsells for additional features.
- Pinhole Press Photo Books:
- Key Features: Focus on minimalist, elegant design with high-quality printing. Known for premium layflat books and thoughtful presentation.
- Average Price: $70 – $200.
- Pros: Superior craftsmanship, beautiful aesthetic, durable materials, excellent for showcasing a curated collection of photos.
- Cons: Higher price point, fewer design templates compared to some competitors.
- MailPix Custom Photo Prints:
- Key Features: Order individual photo prints in various sizes, posters, and enlargements. Simple upload and ordering process.
- Average Price: $0.09 – $0.50 per print, depending on size and quantity.
- Pros: Economical way to get physical copies of digital photos, great for creating your own albums or displays.
- Cons: Requires manual organization and display post-printing, not a complete “product” on its own.
- Printique Fine Art Prints:
- Key Features: Specializes in high-quality photo printing on various papers, including fine art and metallic options. Offers professional-grade prints for display.
- Average Price: Varies widely based on size and paper type, e.g., $10 for an 8×10 to $100+ for large format.
- Pros: Exceptional archival quality, ideal for framing and gifting significant individual photos, professional-grade results.
- Cons: Higher cost per print, primarily focused on individual prints rather than cohesive albums.
- Custom Engraved Photo Frames:
- Key Features: Personalized photo frames made from wood, metal, or other materials, often with custom text or dates engraved.
- Average Price: $20 – $60.
- Pros: Tangible, decorative, and personal gift. Can display a single cherished memory beautifully. Lasting physical item.
- Cons: Displays only one photo at a time, may require finding a suitable photo to print separately.
Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.
IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.
52memories.com Review & First Look
When you land on 52memories.com, the immediate impression is one of a sleek, visually appealing site with a clear, heartwarming concept: turning wedding memories into a year-long physical keepsake. The idea itself is genuinely charming.
Imagine getting a surprise postcard with a cherished photo and a heartfelt message from your wedding, every single week, for 52 weeks straight. That’s the core promise.
The homepage highlights this unique selling proposition right away, emphasizing “The ultimate wedding gift” and “Memories of the most exciting day of your life for a whole year.”
The design is clean, with crisp imagery of postcards and happy couples.
Navigation is intuitive, guiding visitors through the service’s benefits and how it works. Personalizedpaths.com Review
They use a visual timeline to illustrate the weekly delivery, which is a nice touch.
However, as someone who values full transparency, the initial lack of clear, upfront pricing information on the main landing page is notable.
You see “Order now” buttons, but no immediate price tags.
This necessitates clicking through to another page to get the actual cost, which isn’t ideal for quick comparison shopping.
While not a deal-breaker, it’s a common point of friction for users who prefer all essential details front and center. Unlockingonline.com Review
The website also emphasizes ease of use for guests, detailing a four-step process for creating their photo postcards via a web app: scanning a QR code, uploading a photo, adding text, and selecting a shipping date.
This streamlined approach for contributors is definitely a plus.
They also offer a “test card” and a “paper sample” for free, which is a strong move for building trust and demonstrating print quality.
This kind of tangible proof can be a real differentiator in the online service space.
Understanding the 52memories.com Concept
The entire premise of 52memories.com revolves around transforming fleeting digital memories into lasting, physical artifacts delivered over an extended period. Essaytoday.net Review
Think of it as a reverse social media feed, but instead of endless scrolling, you get a curated, tangible piece of your special day arriving in your mailbox each week.
The core functionality relies on wedding guests acting as contributors.
At the wedding, or even post-event, guests are encouraged to use a web app by scanning a QR code.
This digital gateway allows them to upload a personal photo perhaps a selfie with the couple, a candid moment from the reception, or a scenic shot and pen a congratulatory message or a funny anecdote.
What sets 52memories apart is how these individual contributions are then managed and delivered. Ryanpethouse.com Review
Instead of sending out all cards at once, the system intelligently schedules each card for a unique future mailing date over the course of a year.
This ensures the “surprise” element is maintained for 52 consecutive weeks.
The value proposition isn’t just about the postcards themselves.
It’s about the prolonged experience of reliving the wedding.
Many couples might receive a flurry of gifts and well-wishes right after the big day, but the weekly delivery from 52memories extends that joyous feeling, offering little bursts of happiness throughout their first year of marriage. Hargatehill.com Review
This unique delivery mechanism is a significant differentiator compared to traditional photo albums or single-delivery gift items.
However, the question of long-term archival beyond the 52 weeks is something to consider.
While you receive physical postcards, the digital originals and the app interface’s accessibility after the service period aren’t explicitly highlighted on the main page.
This could be a minor concern for those who prefer to have a digital backup or access to their full collection in a single digital repository.
How 52memories.com Works: The Guest and Couple Experience
The operational flow of 52memories.com is designed to be seamless for both wedding guests contributing memories and the newlyweds receiving them. Otubio.com Review
This dual-sided approach requires efficient digital tools and robust logistical planning.
Guest Contribution Process
For guests, the process is streamlined into four easy steps:
- Scan the QR Code: Guests are provided with a QR code presumably on a flyer at the wedding, or accessible via a website link. Scanning this code with their cell phone or visiting the specified web address logs them into the 52memories web app. This ensures accessibility for anyone with a smartphone, minimizing friction.
- Upload a Photo: Once logged in, guests can upload a photo. This could be a picture they took at the event, a selfie, or even a pre-existing photo they feel is relevant. The app also offers “favorite filter” options, allowing for some basic photo enhancement, which is a nice touch for those who want to quickly spruce up their images.
- Add Your Greeting Text: This is where the personal touch comes in. Guests can write their congratulations, well-wishes, inside jokes, or funny anecdotes for the back of the postcard. This personal message is crucial as it adds the narrative and emotional context to the photo.
- Select a Shipping Date: This is a key feature that prevents all cards from being sent out simultaneously. The system automatically selects the first available free date in the year, but guests have the option to manually change this date. The important constraint is that only dates for which no postcard has already been saved are available for selection, ensuring a unique delivery schedule for each card. This scheduling mechanism is crucial for the “weekly surprise” aspect of the service.
The entire guest experience is designed to be quick and intuitive, encouraging maximum participation.
By making it mobile-friendly and offering simple creative tools, they aim to lower the barrier to entry for contributions.
Newlywed Experience
For the newlyweds, the experience is passive and delightful: Slidingwardrobesunlimited.com Review
- Weekly Surprises: The core of the service is the anticipation and joy of receiving a new, personalized photo postcard in their mailbox every week for a year. This transforms the initial wedding excitement into a sustained, long-term celebration of their union and the people who shared it with them.
- Worldwide Shipping: 52memories.com emphasizes that cards are shipped worldwide at no extra cost. This is a significant benefit for couples who might move or live internationally, ensuring continuity of the service regardless of their location. The website explicitly states: “We ensure that the cards will be sent anywhere in the world, no matter where the newlyweds live – provided that the local mail system functions properly.” This global reach is a strong selling point.
- Address Changes: The service accommodates address changes, allowing newlyweds to update their mailing address in their login area. This flexibility is critical for a service that spans a full year, as couples often move during this period. “We’ll find it! You can change the address in your login area. The postcards will be mailed out as usual. Anytime. Worldwide. Without additional costs.” This proactive solution addresses a common logistical concern.
The entire process, from guest contribution to couple reception, is engineered for convenience and surprise, aiming to extend the joy of the wedding day throughout the first year of marriage.
52memories.com Pros & Cons
Delving into the advantages and disadvantages of 52memories.com provides a balanced perspective, helping potential users make an informed decision.
Pros:
- Unique and Memorable Gift: The primary advantage is the distinctiveness of the gift. Instead of a single item, it offers a year-long experience of receiving personalized memories. This continuous stream of well-wishes can be incredibly touching and stand out from traditional wedding presents.
- Sentimental Value: The service taps deeply into emotional appeal. Each postcard is a physical reminder of a cherished moment or a heartfelt message from a loved one. This sentimental value is hard to quantify but is often priceless to recipients.
- Extends Wedding Joy: The weekly delivery extends the excitement and joy of the wedding day for an entire year, providing regular, positive surprises that can brighten any week. This sustained engagement is a unique benefit.
- Global Reach: With worldwide shipping included and the ability to update addresses, 52memories.com caters to couples living anywhere, making it a truly international gift option. This flexibility is a significant plus in an increasingly globalized world.
- Ease of Guest Contribution: The four-step web app process for guests is simple and intuitive, making it easy for friends and family to contribute their photos and messages without technical hurdles. This encourages higher participation rates.
- “Heartbeat Guarantee” Money-Back Policy: Their “Heartbeat Guarantee” offers a full refund if not satisfied, “no matter when and for whatever reason.” This strong commitment to customer satisfaction significantly reduces risk for the purchaser and speaks to their confidence in the service.
- Free Test Card & Sample: Offering a free test card design and a paper sample allows potential customers to experience the quality firsthand before committing, which builds trust and addresses common concerns about print quality.
Cons:
- Lack of Upfront Pricing on Homepage: As mentioned, the main landing page does not immediately display package pricing. Users must click “Order now” to discover the costs, which can be an inconvenience and a barrier for those seeking quick information.
- Reliance on Guest Participation: The success and richness of the gift depend entirely on guests actively contributing. If few guests participate, the newlyweds might receive fewer cards, or some weeks might be blank, diminishing the intended effect.
- Digital Archival Ambiguity: While physical postcards are delivered, the website doesn’t explicitly detail the long-term digital archival of the submitted photos and messages. Do users retain access to a digital gallery after the 52 weeks? This information isn’t immediately clear.
- Potential for Repetitive Content: Depending on guest submissions, there’s a slight chance of similar photos or messages appearing if many guests upload generic shots from the same angle. The system aims to distribute dates, but content variety relies on guest creativity.
- No Explicit Data Privacy Policy Link: While contact information is present, a direct, prominent link to a detailed data privacy policy on the homepage would enhance transparency regarding how guest photos and personal information are handled.
- Physical Mail Dependency: The service relies on the efficiency of local postal services worldwide. While 52memories.com promises global shipping, issues with mail delivery in certain regions could impact the weekly surprise experience.
- Limited Customization Beyond Text/Filter: While guests can add text and apply a filter, the customization options for the postcard design itself seem limited to a standard format, which might not appeal to those seeking highly personalized design choices.
52memories.com Pricing
Understanding the pricing structure of any service is crucial, and 52memories.com handles this by directing users to a specific “Order now” page.
While not immediately visible on the main landing page, once you navigate to the ordering section, the pricing becomes clear, indicating different “sizes” or packages tailored to varying needs and potential guest counts.
Based on typical online service models for personalized products, pricing often scales with the volume or duration of the service. For 52memories.com, this would logically mean: Firstsiteguide.com Review
- Package Tiers: The service likely offers different tiers or packages, possibly based on the number of postcards included or the expected number of guest contributions. A larger package might accommodate more guest submissions, ensuring a more diverse collection of weekly postcards.
- “Always included” Features: The website does state that “Always included” features across all sizes are:
- ❤️Worldwide shipping: This is a significant value add, eliminating concerns about international delivery costs.
- ❤️Excellent print quality: Assuring users of the physical product’s standard.
- ❤️Easy login with QR code flyer: Highlighting the seamless guest contribution process.
- All-Inclusive Pricing: The FAQ section clarifies that “All costs really included in the prices of 52memories? Of course! Everything’s included in the prices quoted, from on-time printing to weekly shipping worldwide.” This means there are no hidden fees for printing, processing, or international postage, which is a strong point for transparency once the price is revealed.
Typical Pricing Models for Similar Services Illustrative, actual pricing varies:
Given the unique, year-long delivery model, 52memories.com’s pricing likely falls into a higher bracket than a one-time photo book but provides extended value. For comparison, custom photo album services can range from $20 to $300+ depending on size and features, while personalized print services often charge per print.
Hypothetically, 52memories.com might offer packages such as:
- Basic Package: Covering a certain number of postcard submissions e.g., up to 52 for one per week, assuming maximum participation. This would be the entry point.
- Standard Package: Allowing for a higher number of submissions or perhaps guaranteeing a minimum number of distinct postcards.
- Premium Package: Potentially including more design customization options, expedited processing for certain initial cards, or dedicated support.
To get the exact pricing, users must click the “Order now” button. This navigation is a minor hurdle, but once overcome, the clear statement about all-inclusive costs is reassuring. For a service promising 52 weeks of tangible, personalized memories, the pricing would need to reflect the ongoing printing, processing, and shipping logistics involved. It’s a premium experience, and the cost should align with that.
52memories.com vs. Traditional Photo Albums
When it comes to preserving wedding memories, 52memories.com offers a distinctly different approach compared to traditional photo albums. Rentacarlasrosas.com Review
Both serve the purpose of memorializing the special day, but their methods, experiences, and long-term value propositions diverge significantly.
52memories.com: The Distributed, Surprise Experience
- Format: Individual, weekly physical postcards delivered over a year.
- Content Source: Primarily guest-contributed photos and personal messages, often candid and varied.
- Experience: A prolonged, ongoing surprise and delight. Each week brings a new memory, extending the joy of the wedding day. It’s a continuous, unfolding narrative.
- Tangibility: High tangibility for each individual postcard, but the collection is dispersed over time.
- Convenience: Very convenient for the recipients the newlyweds as the memories arrive directly in their mailbox. For guests, it’s a simple app-based contribution.
- Archival: Physical postcards exist, but digital archival of the full collection in one accessible place is not explicitly highlighted.
- Cost: Likely a premium for the year-long service, including printing and worldwide shipping for 52 distinct items.
- Best For: Couples who love surprises, value personal anecdotes from guests, and want to continuously relive their wedding day throughout their first year of marriage. It’s an excellent gift for its novelty and sustained emotional impact.
Traditional Photo Albums: The Centralized, Curated Keepsake
- Format: A single, bound physical book containing a curated collection of photos.
- Content Source: Typically professional wedding photos, but can also include curated guest photos. Content is usually highly edited and selected for aesthetic appeal and narrative flow.
- Experience: A one-time, comprehensive viewing experience. Flipping through an album tells the story of the day from start to finish. It’s a complete, singular object.
- Tangibility: High tangibility for the entire collection in one cohesive volume.
- Convenience: Requires effort in photo selection, editing, and layout design. Can be time-consuming for the couple or gift-giver to compile.
- Archival: A physical, durable keepsake that serves as a complete archive of selected memories. Digital copies of professional photos are usually provided separately.
- Cost: Varies widely, from affordable DIY options to high-end, custom-designed professional albums costing hundreds or thousands.
- Best For: Couples who desire a professionally curated, complete visual narrative of their wedding day. Ideal for displaying on a coffee table, sharing with visitors, and traditional long-term preservation of key moments.
Key Differences and Considerations:
- Storytelling: Photo albums tell a sequential, curated story. 52memories.com offers a more fragmented, surprising, and often more personal narrative driven by guest perspectives.
- Effort: Traditional albums require significant upfront effort in selection and design. 52memories.com shifts the effort to guests for contributions and the service handles the rest for delivery.
- Longevity of Surprise: 52memories.com provides a sustained feeling of the wedding throughout a year. Traditional albums offer an immediate, comprehensive memory artifact.
- Collection vs. Dispersal: An album is a single, unified collection. The postcards are a distributed collection, potentially requiring the couple to compile them into their own album or display method.
Ultimately, neither is inherently “better”. they cater to different preferences for how memories are preserved and experienced.
52memories.com offers a novel, ongoing delight, while a traditional photo album provides a timeless, comprehensive chronicle.
For many, a combination of both might be ideal, with the album capturing the professional highlights and 52memories.com adding unique, personal touches throughout the first year.
How to Cancel 52memories.com Subscription / Money-Back Guarantee
When considering any online service, especially one involving a year-long commitment, understanding the cancellation policy and money-back guarantee is paramount. Accountingbiz.co Review
52memories.com addresses this directly on its homepage through its prominent “Heartbeat Guarantee.”
The “Heartbeat Guarantee”
52memories.com offers a very clear and reassuring refund policy:
- Full Purchase Price Refund: “If you’re not satisfied with 52memories – no matter when and for whatever reason – we’ll refund you the full purchase price.”
- No Time Limit Stated: The phrase “no matter when” is particularly strong, implying that the refund isn’t limited to a short trial period or specific number of days post-purchase. This level of confidence in their service is unusual and commendable.
- No Reason Required: “for whatever reason” further simplifies the refund process, removing the need for customers to provide specific justifications for dissatisfaction.
This “Heartbeat Guarantee” is a significant positive point, as it drastically reduces the financial risk for customers.
It suggests that the company is confident in its service quality and willing to stand behind its product without caveats.
How to Cancel / Request a Refund Based on available information
While the website details the guarantee, it doesn’t provide a direct, step-by-step guide on how to initiate a cancellation or refund request on the main page. Newportfasteners.com Review
However, based on standard online business practices and the information present:
- Contact Customer Support: The most direct method would be to contact 52memories.com’s customer service. The website includes an “All FAQ & Contact” link. This section would typically provide an email address, phone number, or a contact form. For instance, an email address like
[email protected]
is listed for ordering a paper sample, suggesting it’s a general contact point. - Provide Order Details: When contacting them, you would likely need to provide your order number, the email address used for the purchase, and perhaps the name of the couple for whom the service was purchased.
- State Your Request: Clearly state that you wish to cancel the service and receive a full refund, referencing their “Heartbeat Guarantee.”
- Confirm Cancellation: Ensure you receive confirmation of the cancellation and the processing of your refund.
Important Note on “Subscription” vs. “One-Time Purchase”:
The term “subscription” might imply recurring payments. However, for a wedding gift service like this, it is likely a one-time purchase for the year-long service. The “Heartbeat Guarantee” makes it clear that even if it’s a one-time payment, dissatisfaction at any point can lead to a full refund, which is more generous than many subscription cancellation policies.
This robust guarantee significantly enhances trust and reduces buyer’s remorse, making the service more appealing to those who might be hesitant about a unique, year-long commitment.
FAQ
What is 52memories.com?
52memories.com is an online service that transforms wedding guest photos and messages into personalized postcards, which are then printed and mailed weekly to newlyweds for an entire year as a unique wedding gift.
How does 52memories.com work for wedding guests?
Wedding guests use a web app by scanning a QR code or visiting a website, then upload a photo, add a personal greeting text, and select a desired future mailing date for their postcard. Oneclickfromdate.com Review
How do newlyweds receive their postcards from 52memories.com?
Newlyweds receive one personalized photo postcard in their physical mailbox every week for 52 weeks, delivered as a surprise.
Can I try 52memories.com before buying?
Yes, 52memories.com offers the option to design a test card online and request a free paper sample to experience the print quality firsthand.
Is worldwide shipping included with 52memories.com?
Yes, 52memories.com explicitly states that worldwide shipping is included in the price, with no extra cost for international delivery.
What is the “Heartbeat Guarantee” from 52memories.com?
The “Heartbeat Guarantee” is 52memories.com’s money-back policy, promising a full refund of the purchase price if you’re not satisfied, “no matter when and for whatever reason.”
What if the newlyweds move their address during the 52 weeks?
52memories.com allows address changes in the user’s login area, ensuring that postcards will continue to be mailed to the updated address worldwide, without additional costs. Landlordleaseforms.com Review
Are all costs truly included in the price of 52memories.com?
Yes, 52memories.com confirms that all costs, including on-time printing and weekly worldwide shipping, are included in the prices quoted.
How does 52memories.com ensure postcards are sent throughout the year?
When a guest creates a postcard, the system automatically selects the first free mailing date in the year, which can be manually changed to another available date, preventing multiple cards from being sent on the same day.
Is 52memories.com a one-time purchase or a subscription?
Based on the service description, it appears to be a one-time purchase for a year-long service, rather than a recurring subscription, though this is not explicitly stated.
How do I contact 52memories.com for support or questions?
52memories.com provides an “All FAQ & Contact” section on their website, and an email address [email protected] is listed for paper sample requests, which likely serves as a general contact point.
What kind of photos can guests upload to 52memories.com?
Guests can upload any photo or selfie they choose, and the web app also offers filter options to enhance the image. Smartaffair.eu Review
Can guests choose a specific filter for their photos on 52memories.com?
Yes, guests can choose their “favorite filter” within the web app when uploading their photo for the postcard.
What kind of text can guests add to their postcards on 52memories.com?
Guests can write congratulations, well-wishes, funny messages, or any personal greeting for the back of the postcard.
Does 52memories.com offer different package sizes?
Yes, the website mentions that “52memories is available in different sizes,” implying various packages or tiers, though specific details are not on the main page.
What ethical considerations should I be aware of with 52memories.com?
The service itself is ethically sound.
The main point to consider is the initial lack of upfront pricing details on the homepage, which requires navigation to another page for full transparency. Connectly.org Review
How does 52memories.com compare to traditional photo albums?
52memories.com offers a unique, year-long, distributed surprise experience of individual postcards, while traditional photo albums provide a single, curated, comprehensive physical keepsake of all memories.
Are there any hidden fees with 52memories.com?
No, according to their FAQ, all costs are included in the quoted prices, covering printing and worldwide weekly shipping.
What happens if I’m not satisfied with 52memories.com after a few months?
According to their “Heartbeat Guarantee,” you can receive a full refund if you’re not satisfied, “no matter when” during the service period.
Can I personalize the design of the postcards with 52memories.com?
While guests can choose photos and add text, the level of design customization beyond these elements and a filter isn’t explicitly detailed on the main page, suggesting a standard postcard layout is used.
Leave a Reply