Propfirmroom.com Review

Based on looking at the website, Propfirmroom.com appears to be a platform that aggregates and reviews proprietary trading firms, often referred to as “prop firms.” While it aims to provide insights and discount codes for these firms, the very nature of prop trading, which often involves elements of risk and potential for interest-based dealings or speculative ventures, raises significant concerns from an Islamic perspective.

The site’s primary function is to direct users to platforms that engage in activities often seen as highly speculative or potentially containing Riba interest, which is strictly forbidden in Islam.

Overall Review Summary:

• Website Purpose: Aggregates and reviews proprietary trading firms, offering discount codes.
• Ethical Compliance Islamic: Not compliant. The core business model revolves around speculative trading, which can involve Riba and excessive risk gharar.
• Transparency: Provides some basic firm details, but lacks comprehensive disclosures typically found on independent review sites, such as detailed methodology or regulatory information.
• User Engagement: Offers discount codes and links to Trustpilot reviews, but the primary call to action is to join prop firms.
• Missing Information: Lacks a clear “About Us” section, detailed terms of service, privacy policy, or a robust disclaimer regarding the inherent risks of trading. There’s no clear indication of how firms are vetted beyond “deeply analyzes.”
• Recommendation: Not recommended due to the inherent conflict with Islamic financial principles, particularly regarding speculative trading and potential for interest.

Propfirmroom.com positions itself as a central hub for individuals interested in proprietary trading, a field where traders are given capital by a firm to trade financial markets.

The allure of “real daily payout” and significant discount codes is a strong draw.

However, the fundamental operations within prop trading can often skirt ethical lines from an Islamic standpoint.

Many of these firms operate on models that might include swap fees interest on overnight positions, high leverage excessive risk, and dealing in derivatives that might not involve real underlying assets.

The website itself acts as an affiliate, directing traffic to these firms, thus participating in the ecosystem.

While it presents itself as a review platform with star ratings and “highly recommended” labels, the absence of crucial information like a clear business model beyond affiliate marketing, or a detailed breakdown of how their “deep analysis” is conducted, raises questions about its impartiality and comprehensive due diligence.

Find detailed reviews on Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org, for software products you can also check Producthunt.

IMPORTANT: We have not personally tested this company’s services. This review is based solely on information provided by the company on their website. For independent, verified user experiences, please refer to trusted sources such as Trustpilot, Reddit, and BBB.org.

Better Alternatives for Ethical Earning and Investment

For those seeking to build wealth or generate income in ways that align with Islamic principles, the focus should shift away from speculative ventures like prop trading and towards real, tangible assets, ethical business practices, and knowledge acquisition. Here are some ethically sound alternatives:

• Halal Investment Funds: Invest in Sharia-compliant equities, Sukuk Islamic bonds, and real estate investment trusts REITs that avoid forbidden industries alcohol, gambling, conventional finance, etc. and interest-bearing instruments. Many reputable financial institutions offer these.
  • Key Features: Adherence to Sharia principles, professional management, diversification.
  • Average Price: Varies based on fund type and management fees typically 0.5% – 2% annually.
  • Pros: Sharia-compliant, expert management, passive income potential, supports ethical businesses.
  • Cons: Market volatility, fees can eat into returns, limited investment universe compared to conventional funds.
• Ethical Entrepreneurship & E-commerce: Start a business selling physical products or services that provide real value. This can be anything from a local service business to an online store. The emphasis is on honest trade and fair dealings.
  • Key Features: Direct control, value creation, often scalable.
  • Average Price: Varies widely, from low-cost online ventures to significant startup capital for physical businesses.
  • Pros: Fulfills the Islamic emphasis on trade, direct impact, potential for high returns, creative freedom.
  • Cons: High risk, significant time and effort, market competition.
• Real Estate Investment: Invest in properties for rental income or capital appreciation. Ensure financing is Sharia-compliant e.g., Murabaha or Ijarah structures, avoiding conventional mortgages with interest.
  • Key Features: Tangible asset, potential for passive income and appreciation.
  • Average Price: High barrier to entry for direct purchase, but REITs offer lower entry points.
  • Pros: Stable asset class, inflation hedge, provides real utility housing/commercial space.
  • Cons: Illiquid, high maintenance costs, market fluctuations.
• Skill Development & Consulting: Acquire valuable skills e.g., programming, marketing, design, writing and offer your services as a freelancer or consultant. This involves exchanging effort for honest earnings.
  • Key Features: Leverage personal expertise, flexible work arrangements, low overhead.
  • Average Price: Initial investment in courses or certifications $100 – $5,000+.
  • Pros: Direct income from effort, continuous learning, high demand for specialized skills.
  • Cons: Income can be inconsistent, requires self-discipline, constant need to update skills.
• Agricultural Ventures: Invest in or operate agricultural projects, focusing on producing food or other beneficial crops. This aligns with productive economic activity and providing for society’s needs.
  • Key Features: Tangible output, contributes to food security.
  • Average Price: Varies significantly based on scale and type of agriculture.
  • Pros: Sustainable, often has a positive environmental impact, provides essential goods.
  • Cons: Labor-intensive, susceptible to environmental factors, long gestation periods for returns.
• Sustainable & Ethical Products: Support or invest in businesses that produce and sell ethical, sustainable, and useful products. This could be anything from eco-friendly household goods to modest fashion.
  • Key Features: Focus on positive impact, ethical sourcing, often niche markets.
  • Average Price: Varies.
  • Pros: Aligns with values, contributes to a better society, growing market demand.
  • Cons: Can be more expensive to produce, requires consumer education.
• Crafts & Handmade Goods: Develop skills in a craft and sell handmade items. This could be calligraphy, pottery, textile art, or unique home decor, providing real value through craftsmanship.
  • Key Features: Artistic expression, unique products, direct connection with customers.
  • Average Price: Low startup costs for basic tools, higher for specialized equipment.
  • Pros: Fulfilling, allows for creativity, direct profit from labor.
  • Cons: Can be time-consuming, scaling can be challenging, market saturation in some areas.

Propfirmroom.com: A Deep Dive into a Questionable Model

Propfirmroom.com presents itself as a directory and review site for proprietary trading firms. These firms typically offer individuals capital to trade financial markets, contingent on passing certain evaluations or challenges. While the site features prominent calls to action for “daily payouts” and significant discounts, the underlying financial activities promoted—forex, indices, metals, crypto, and commodities trading—are fraught with complexities and ethical considerations from an Islamic perspective. The lack of transparency regarding how these firms operate concerning interest Riba or excessive uncertainty Gharar makes the entire model highly problematic.

Propfirmroom.com Review & First Look

Upon first glance, Propfirmroom.com immediately highlights “THE ONLY PROP FIRM – WITH REAL DAILY PAYOUT” and offers a “20% OFF” code, creating an immediate sense of urgency and opportunity.

The homepage is dominated by a list of prop firms, each with a star rating, number of reviews, country of operation, years in business, tradable assets, platforms, and maximum allocations.

This presentation is designed to appear as a helpful comparison tool.

However, the critical issue lies in the core business model being promoted.

Proprietary trading, in many forms, involves speculative activities where the element of Riba interest or Gharar excessive uncertainty/gambling-like risk can be prevalent, rendering it impermissible in Islam.

The site’s primary function is to funnel users to these firms, essentially endorsing a practice that carries significant ethical baggage.

• Immediate Impressions: Flashy discounts, urgency, focus on high-risk, high-reward trading.
• Core Offer: A directory of prop firms with basic comparative data.
• Underlying Concern: Promotion of financial activities that are largely considered non-compliant with Islamic finance principles.
• Affiliate Model: The presence of discount codes and “Go to Firm” links strongly suggests an affiliate marketing model, where Propfirmroom.com earns a commission for sign-ups. This is a common practice, but when tied to ethically questionable activities, it raises concerns.

Propfirmroom.com Cons

While Propfirmroom.com aims to be a resource, its significant drawbacks stem directly from the nature of the industry it promotes and its own operational transparency.

The cons far outweigh any perceived benefits when viewed through an ethical lens.

• Promotion of Speculative Trading: The fundamental issue is that the site promotes participation in proprietary trading, which inherently involves highly speculative activities. Trading in derivatives futures, options, CFDs on forex, indices, metals, and cryptocurrencies often involves contracts that are not permissible, as they may lack real underlying assets, involve Riba e.g., overnight swap fees, or have elements of gambling due to extreme leverage and uncertainty.
• Lack of Islamic Ethical Vetting: There is no indication that Propfirmroom.com vets the listed prop firms for Sharia compliance. Given the complexities of Islamic finance, a simple review of “assets” and “platforms” is insufficient to determine if a firm’s trading practices, profit-sharing models, or financial instruments are permissible.
• Potential for Riba Interest: Many prop firms or their underlying brokers charge swap fees on overnight positions, which are a form of Riba. Without explicit statements from Propfirmroom.com or the listed firms about avoiding such fees, users are exposed to interest-based transactions.
• Excessive Risk Gharar: The very nature of leveraged trading, which is common in prop firms, introduces an excessive level of uncertainty Gharar and undue risk. This is akin to gambling, where success is highly dependent on chance and market volatility rather than genuine economic activity.
• Limited Transparency on Vetting Process: The site claims, “Our team deeply analyzes and provides insights on every firm listed on this website.” However, there’s no detailed methodology or criteria disclosed for this “deep analysis.” Users are left to trust their subjective star ratings and “highly recommended” labels without understanding the basis.
• Absence of Critical Website Sections: A legitimate review or informational website typically features comprehensive “About Us,” “Terms of Service,” and “Privacy Policy” sections. Propfirmroom.com appears to lack these crucial pages on its main interface, which is a red flag for transparency and user trust.
• No Risk Disclosures from the Site Itself: While individual prop firms might have disclaimers, Propfirmroom.com itself does not prominently display robust risk disclaimers regarding the inherent dangers of trading, nor does it warn about the financial and ethical pitfalls.
• Affiliate-Driven Content: The pervasive presence of discount codes and direct links to sign-up pages suggests a strong affiliate marketing focus. While not inherently wrong, it can bias reviews or recommendations, leading to a focus on conversion rather than truly impartial advice.
• Focus on Immediate Payouts: The emphasis on “real daily payout” may create unrealistic expectations and encourage rash decisions, playing into the desire for quick, easy money, which is often a hallmark of speculative ventures.

Propfirmroom.com Alternatives

Given the significant ethical issues associated with the proprietary trading model that Propfirmroom.com promotes, it is imperative to seek out alternatives that align with Islamic financial principles. Mcafee.com Review

The focus should shift from speculative gains to tangible assets, ethical business practices, and value creation.

• Halal Investment Platforms: These platforms specialize in Sharia-compliant investments, including equities, Sukuk, and halal REITs. They meticulously screen investments to ensure they avoid interest-based transactions, forbidden industries like alcohol, gambling, arms, conventional banking, and excessive speculation. Examples include Wahed Invest, Amana Mutual Funds, and similar services that cater to ethical investors.
  • Key Features: Sharia-compliant portfolios, professional management, diversification.
  • Pros: Ethical, low effort for managed funds, supports real economic activity.
  • Cons: Returns tied to market performance, management fees.
• Entrepreneurship and Small Business Development: Instead of relying on borrowed capital for speculative trading, focus on building a legitimate business that offers a product or service. This could be e-commerce, consulting, local services, or even agriculture. Islam highly encourages honest trade and earning through effort.
  • Key Features: Direct control, scalability, creation of real value.
  • Pros: Earns honest income, builds tangible assets, contributes to community.
  • Cons: High risk, requires significant time and effort, can be slow to generate profit.
• Vocational Training & Skill Acquisition: Invest in yourself by learning valuable skills like programming, digital marketing, graphic design, plumbing, electrical work, or carpentry. These skills can then be leveraged to offer services and earn a steady, permissible income. Platforms like Coursera, Udemy, and local vocational schools offer various courses.
  • Key Features: Direct income from effort, increased employability.
  • Pros: Low startup costs, high demand for skilled labor, continuous learning.
  • Cons: Requires dedication and time to master skills, income can be inconsistent initially.
• Real Estate Investment Halal Financing: Investing in physical property for rental income or long-term appreciation is a sound, ethical investment. Ensure any financing used is Sharia-compliant, such as Ijara leasing or Murabaha cost-plus financing, rather than conventional interest-based mortgages.
  • Key Features: Tangible asset, potential for stable income and capital growth.
  • Pros: Generally stable, provides essential housing/commercial space, can be inflation-proof.
  • Cons: High capital requirement, illiquidity, maintenance responsibilities.
• Crowdfunding for Ethical Businesses: Explore platforms that facilitate crowdfunding for real businesses or projects that align with Islamic values. This allows individuals to invest in startups or existing businesses that require capital for growth, sharing in actual profits and losses rather than speculative gains.
  • Key Features: Direct investment in real businesses, diverse opportunities.
  • Pros: Supports ethical entrepreneurship, potential for significant returns, aligns with profit/loss sharing.
  • Cons: High risk for startups, returns are not guaranteed, illiquid investment.
• Gold and Silver as Physical Assets: Investing in physical gold and silver, with immediate possession, is permissible and has historically served as a hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty. This is distinct from speculative gold/silver futures or ETFs that don’t involve physical ownership.
  • Key Features: Tangible assets, store of value.
  • Pros: Inflation hedge, long-term wealth preservation, tangible.
  • Cons: Storage costs, price volatility, no income generation.
• Community-Based Ethical Lending/Donation: While not direct income generation, supporting community initiatives through qard hassan interest-free loans or charitable donations strengthens the economic fabric in a permissible way. This fosters a system where needs are met without engaging in Riba.
  • Key Features: Supports social good, strengthens community bonds.
  • Pros: Highly rewarding, helps others, builds positive social capital.
  • Cons: No financial return, focus is on societal benefit.

How to Evaluate a Prop Firm for Ethical Compliance Not Recommended to Engage

Although Propfirmroom.com does not offer this vetting, it’s crucial to understand the principles of why most prop firms fall short. If one were to hypothetically attempt to find a Sharia-compliant prop firm which is highly improbable in practice due to the industry’s nature, these are the criteria that would need to be met. However, the complexity of verifying each aspect makes it almost impossible for an individual. It’s generally safer to avoid this model altogether.

• No Interest Riba Charges: This is paramount. The firm must explicitly state that no swap fees, overnight charges, or any other form of interest is levied on positions held. This includes any financing costs for the “funded” capital.
• Real Trading of Permissible Assets: The trading must involve actual, permissible assets e.g., physical commodities, certain stocks, real estate and not speculative derivatives that are structured like gambling contracts. The contract needs to fulfill the conditions of a valid sale or partnership.
• Absence of Excessive Gharar Uncertainty: Trading mechanisms should not involve excessive uncertainty or ambiguity, akin to gambling. Highly leveraged trading, where small price movements lead to massive gains or losses, often crosses into Gharar.
• Profit-Loss Sharing Mudarabah/Musharakah: If it’s truly a “prop firm” in the sense of a partnership, the relationship should genuinely be one of Mudarabah profit-sharing or Musharakah joint venture, where both parties share in both profits and losses based on pre-agreed ratios. This is highly unlikely in typical prop firm models where the “trader” often bears the initial risk of a challenge fee and is primarily penalized for losses, while the firm guarantees its own capital.
• No Prohibited Instruments: The firm should not allow trading in instruments like conventional bonds, interest-based ETFs, or certain complex derivatives that do not meet Islamic transactional requirements.
• Transparent and Fair Contracts: The contract between the trader and the firm must be clear, transparent, and fair, without deceptive clauses or hidden fees.

Propfirmroom.com Pricing for Affiliate Links

Propfirmroom.com itself doesn’t have a direct “pricing” structure for its own services, as it functions as an affiliate marketing platform. Its revenue model is based on commissions generated when users click through its links and sign up for the listed prop firms, potentially using the provided discount codes. The “pricing” therefore refers to the challenge fees or evaluation costs charged by the prop firms themselves, which Propfirmroom.com is promoting.

• Challenge Fees: Prop firms typically charge an upfront fee for traders to participate in their evaluation or challenge phases. These fees can range from $50 to several thousands of dollars, depending on the size of the “funded” account being sought.
• Discount Codes: Propfirmroom.com prominently features discount codes e.g., “ROOM,” “WELCOME30,” “ALPHA20” which reduce these challenge fees. This is a common incentive used in affiliate marketing to drive conversions. For example, a “20% OFF” code on a $500 challenge fee would save the user $100, while Propfirmroom.com still earns a commission on the discounted purchase.
• Ongoing Fees from Prop Firms: Beyond the initial challenge fee, some prop firms may have ongoing subscription fees, data fees, or commissions on trades, although the primary cost for the “funded” trader is usually tied to hitting loss limits.
• Profit Split: The main “earning” mechanism for traders with prop firms is a profit split, where a percentage of the profits generated e.g., 70-90% for the trader, 10-30% for the firm is allocated to the trader. This profit split is what ultimately drives interest in prop firms.
• The Ethical Cost: From an Islamic perspective, even if the direct price appears reasonable, the ethical cost of engaging in these potentially Riba-laden and highly speculative activities is paramount. The “price” isn’t just monetary. it’s also a moral and spiritual one.

Propfirmroom.com vs. Direct Engagement with Ethical Investing

Comparing Propfirmroom.com to direct engagement with ethical investing models is like comparing apples to very different oranges.

Propfirmroom.com leads down a path of high-risk, potentially impermissible trading, whereas ethical investing focuses on real economic activity and Sharia compliance.

• Propfirmroom.com Model:
  • Focus: Speculative trading, often leveraging borrowed capital for short-term gains.
  • Financial Instruments: Forex, indices, metals, crypto, commodities – frequently via CFDs or futures which may involve Riba or Gharar.
  • Risk Profile: Extremely high, with significant potential for rapid capital loss, even if not directly the trader’s initial capital beyond the challenge fee.
  • Ethical Stance: Highly questionable due to the prevalence of Riba and Gharar in the underlying activities.
  • Accessibility: Relatively easy entry for those looking to trade without personal capital.
• Direct Engagement with Ethical Investing:
  • Focus: Long-term wealth building, real economic growth, asset ownership.
  • Financial Instruments: Sharia-compliant stocks, Sukuk, real estate, physical commodities, ethical businesses.
  • Risk Profile: Moderate to low, depending on asset allocation and diversification.
  • Ethical Stance: Designed to be fully compliant with Islamic principles, avoiding Riba, Gharar, and prohibited industries.
  • Accessibility: Requires diligence in research or engagement with specialized halal financial institutions.

Key Difference: The fundamental difference lies in the source and nature of the potential earnings. Propfirmroom.com promotes an avenue where earnings might be derived from highly speculative market movements, often involving impermissible elements. Ethical investing, on the other hand, focuses on deriving income from real economic activity, asset ownership, and productive ventures, ensuring that the wealth generated is permissible and blessed.

How to Cancel Propfirmroom.com Subscription / Free Trial

Propfirmroom.com, as an affiliate platform, does not appear to offer a direct subscription service or free trial for itself. Its primary function is to link users to third-party prop firms. Therefore, if a user has signed up for a service through Propfirmroom.com’s links, they would need to manage their subscription or free trial directly with the specific prop firm they joined.

Steps to Cancel a Subscription/Trial with a Prop Firm:

1. Identify the Specific Prop Firm: Determine which prop firm you signed up with e.g., FTMO, FundedNext, FunderPro, etc.. Propfirmroom.com simply directs you to their sites.
2. Locate the Firm’s Website: Navigate to the official website of that specific prop firm.
3. Check Their Terms of Service/FAQs: Look for sections related to “Cancellation Policy,” “Refunds,” “Account Management,” or “Subscription Terms.” This information is usually found in the footer, an FAQ section, or a dedicated “Help” or “Support” page.
4. Contact Customer Support: If you cannot find the necessary information, or if the process isn’t straightforward, contact the prop firm’s customer support directly. This can usually be done via email, a contact form on their website, or sometimes a live chat.
   • Be Specific: Clearly state your account details username, email and your intent to cancel.
   • Request Confirmation: Ask for a written confirmation of your cancellation.
5. Review Bank/Payment Statements: After cancellation, monitor your bank or credit card statements to ensure no further charges are debited from the prop firm.
6. No Direct Cancellation with Propfirmroom.com: It’s important to reiterate that Propfirmroom.com has no direct control over your subscriptions with the third-party prop firms. Cancelling with Propfirmroom.com is not applicable, as it doesn’t offer a subscription model itself. If you wish to stop receiving updates or emails from Propfirmroom.com if they have a mailing list, you would look for an unsubscribe link in their emails.

FAQ

What is Propfirmroom.com?

Propfirmroom.com is a website that aggregates and reviews various proprietary trading firms, providing users with information about these firms and offering discount codes for their challenge programs. Flagco.com Review

Is Propfirmroom.com a prop firm itself?

No, Propfirmroom.com is not a proprietary trading firm.

It acts as an affiliate marketing platform, linking users to other prop firms and earning commissions from sign-ups.

What kind of financial activities do prop firms promoted by Propfirmroom.com engage in?

Prop firms promoted by Propfirmroom.com engage in trading financial instruments such as Forex, indices, metals, cryptocurrencies, and commodities, often using high leverage.

Are the financial activities promoted on Propfirmroom.com permissible in Islam?

Generally, the speculative nature of proprietary trading and the potential for involvement in Riba interest or Gharar excessive uncertainty/gambling-like risk make most of the financial activities promoted on Propfirmroom.com not permissible in Islam.

Does Propfirmroom.com provide any ethical or Sharia compliance vetting for the listed firms?

Based on the website’s content, there is no indication that Propfirmroom.com performs any specific ethical or Sharia compliance vetting for the prop firms it lists.

What are the main ethical concerns with prop trading from an Islamic perspective?

The main ethical concerns include the potential for Riba e.g., swap fees on overnight positions, excessive Gharar due to high leverage and speculation, and the lack of a true profit-loss sharing partnership Mudarabah/Musharakah in many models.

Does Propfirmroom.com offer a direct subscription or free trial for its own services?

No, Propfirmroom.com does not appear to offer a direct subscription service or free trial for its own platform, as its model is based on affiliate marketing for third-party prop firms.

How does Propfirmroom.com make money?

Propfirmroom.com likely makes money through affiliate commissions.

When users click on their links and sign up for a prop firm, especially using their discount codes, Propfirmroom.com earns a percentage of the fees paid by the user.

What information does Propfirmroom.com provide about each prop firm?

Propfirmroom.com provides basic information about each listed prop firm, including star ratings, number of reviews, country of operation, years in business, tradable assets, platforms, and maximum allocations. Remixshop.com Review

Are the “reviews” on Propfirmroom.com independent and unbiased?

While Propfirmroom.com lists star ratings and review counts often linking to Trustpilot, its affiliate model means there is an inherent financial incentive to promote sign-ups, which could affect the impartiality of its “highly recommended” labels.

What are some better, ethically compliant alternatives to prop trading?

Better alternatives include investing in Halal investment funds, starting an ethical small business, pursuing vocational training for skill-based income, investing in real estate with halal financing, or participating in ethical crowdfunding.

How can I cancel a subscription with a prop firm I found through Propfirmroom.com?

To cancel a subscription or trial, you must directly contact the specific prop firm you joined.

Propfirmroom.com is not involved in managing those accounts.

Refer to the prop firm’s own website for their cancellation policy and customer support contact.

Does Propfirmroom.com have an “About Us” section or transparent terms of service?

Based on the provided homepage text, a prominent “About Us” section, detailed terms of service, or a privacy policy page are not immediately apparent on Propfirmroom.com’s main interface.

Why is investing in physical gold and silver considered a better alternative?

Investing in physical gold and silver, with immediate possession, is considered a permissible and ethical alternative because it involves tangible assets as a store of value, avoiding Riba and excessive speculation common in derivatives.

What is the role of discount codes on Propfirmroom.com?

Discount codes on Propfirmroom.com are incentives used to encourage users to sign up with the listed prop firms, offering a reduction on the challenge fees charged by those firms.

Does Propfirmroom.com offer customer support?

Propfirmroom.com lists an email address [email protected] for inquiries, indicating some form of customer contact.

What is “daily payout” in the context of prop firms?

“Daily payout” refers to the claim that some prop firms allow traders to withdraw their share of profits on a daily basis, once certain conditions like minimum profit thresholds are met. Fivestaralliance.com Review

Is high leverage permissible in Islamic finance?

High leverage, commonly used in prop trading, is generally discouraged in Islamic finance due to the excessive Gharar uncertainty and risk it introduces, which can lead to gambling-like outcomes.

What are some examples of Halal investment platforms?

Examples of Halal investment platforms include Wahed Invest, Amana Mutual Funds, and similar services that offer portfolios screened for Sharia compliance in stocks, Sukuk, and other permissible assets.

Why is ethical entrepreneurship encouraged as an alternative?

Ethical entrepreneurship is encouraged because it involves earning income through honest trade, providing real value through products or services, and contributing to the economy in a permissible and productive manner.